I once read in a book that, when raising children, you can resort to force—including hitting them—to get them to pray. It even cited a hadith about this. Unfortunately, I don’t have the book now, so I can’t check exactly what it said. I wanted to know whether this is true and whether there is really such a recommendation.
Can Force Be Used in Raising a Child?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
A hadith with a weak chain of transmission states that a child may be encouraged to pray from the age of seven and, if necessary, made to do so through corporal punishment after the age of nine. However, the punishment must not be severe or intended to coerce the child; it should be administered with restraint and accompanied by affection.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterA hadith with a weak chain of transmission has been reported in this regard!
عن أبی عبد الله أو أبی جعفر ع فی حدیث قال سمعته یقول یترک الغلام حتى یتم له سبع سنین فإذا تم له سبع سنین قیل له اغسل وجهک و کفیک فإذا غسلهما قیل له صل ثم یترک حتى یتم له تسع سنین فإذا تمت له علم الوضوء و ضرب علیه و أمر بالصلاه و ضرب علیها فإذا تعلم الوضوء و الصلاه غفر الله لوالدیه إن شاء الله.
وسائل الشیعه، ج4، ص: 20
When a child turns seven, tell him to wash his hands and face and to pray. But when he turns nine, teach him how to perform ablution properly, firmly instruct him to pray and, if necessary, you may use corporal punishment to make him pray.
A note!!!
If we are to rely on this hadith, we must keep several points in mind!
The punishment should not be severe; it should be no more than a show of force!
The point is not to use punishment to force or coerce a child into praying, since the clear wording of the verse «لا اکراه فی الدین..» rejects such violence. Prayer performed out of fear of being beaten is meaningless!
If we know that the child has accepted prayer and reached a heartfelt conviction, but is lax in performing it, then we may take a sensible approach and use force judiciously to compel the child to fulfill this duty. But we should also offer explanations and encouragement, and instill affection, so that we can manage the bitterness of measured firmness and turn it into the sweetness of encouragement!