Respected teacher, you have answered several questions about riba. I have another question on this subject: When we take out a bank loan, or buy a car in installments or a house with a bank loan, and pay the bank interest on the money we borrowed, does the borrower—who repays this interest along with the principal—incur riba, or is only the lender involved in riba? I would be grateful if you could explain.
Does a borrower who pays interest on a bank loan incur riba?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
A bank-loan borrower incurs riba if the transaction is merely a formality and the interest to be paid has been fixed in advance. If the transaction is genuine, complies with Islamic law, and the return is generated through real economic activity, there is no problem. In sham transactions or when the rules are treated casually, both parties to the contract are involved in riba.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe parties to a contract or transaction, whether individuals or legal entities, must conduct it in accordance with Islamic law, with full knowledge and understanding, and as a genuine transaction. Any vagueness or ambiguity will render the transaction religiously invalid.
Any profit earned must arise from a Sharia-compliant transaction. A sham contract, or any laxity in this regard, will taint the resulting profit with usury, leaving both parties indebted.