Peace be upon you. Esteemed teacher, is there a hadith stating that anyone who does not visit their parents’ graves is undutiful to them? If so, what about someone who cannot visit for reasons such as the distance? Would they still be considered undutiful? (On behalf of my parents, I do acts of kindness, give charity, and so on.)
Does Failing to Visit One’s Parents’ Graves Make One Undutiful to Them?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Being unable to visit one’s parents’ graves because of the distance or other obstacles does not necessarily make one undutiful to them. A child’s primary duty is to treat their parents well and pray for them; making every effort within one’s means and in light of one’s circumstances is sufficient. Acts of kindness, charity, and prayer after a parent’s death help fulfil the rights they are owed.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThere is no obligation to do what lies beyond one’s capacity. Making an effort within one’s ability, while taking circumstances into account, is sufficient to fulfil the rights incumbent upon one.
فقه الرضا علیه السلام علیک بطاعه الأب و بره و التواضع و الخضوع و الإعظام و الإکرام له و خفض الصوت بحضرته فإن الأب أصل الابن و الابن فرعه لولاه لم یکن یقدره الله ابذلوا لهم الأموال و الجاه و النفس و قد أروی أنت و مالک لأبیک فجعلت له النفس و المال تابعوهم فی الدنیا أحسن المتابعه بالبر و بعد الموت بالدعاء لهم و الترحم علیهم فإنه روی أنه من بر أباه فی حیاته و لم یدع له بعد وفاته سماه الله عاقا و معلم الخیر و الدین یقوم مقام الأب و یجب له مثل الذی یجب له فاعرفوا حقه و اعلم أن حق الأم ألزم الحقوق و أوجب لأنها حملت حیث لا یحمل أحد أحدا و وقت بالسمع و البصر و جمیع الجوارح مسروره مستبشره بذلک فحملته بما فیه من المکروه و الذی لا یصبر علیه أحد رضیت بأن تجوع و یشبع و تظمأ و یروی و تعرى و یکتسی و تظله و تضحى فلیکن الشکر لها و البر و الرفق بها على قدر ذلک و إن کنتم لا تطیقون بأدنى حقها إلا بعون الله و قد قرن الله عز و جل حقها بحقه فقال اشکر لی و لوالدیک إلی المصیر
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج71، ص: 76
Imam al-Rida (AS) said: You must obey your father, treat him with kindness, and show him humility, deference, reverence and respect. Lower your voice in his presence, for a father is the root and his son the branch; had there been no father, the child would not have come into existence by God’s power. Give them your wealth, standing and life. I have heard the saying, “You and your wealth belong to your father,” so give him your life and wealth. Follow your parents in this world with the finest devotion, through kindness, and after their death by praying for them and asking God to have mercy on them. It is related that whoever treats his father well during his lifetime but does not pray for him after his death is deemed by God to be undutiful. A teacher of goodness and religion takes the place of a father, and is entitled to the same rights; therefore, acknowledge his due. Know that a mother’s right is the most binding and the most deserving of fulfilment. She carried her child in a way no one carries another; she watched over the child with her hearing, sight and every limb, all the while happy and glad to do so. She bore the child through hardships that no one could endure, willingly going hungry so the child could eat, thirsty so the child could drink, unclothed so the child could be clothed, and standing in the sun so the child could remain in the shade. So let your gratitude, kindness and gentleness toward her be in proportion to all this—even though you cannot fulfil even the least of her rights without God’s help. God, عز و جل, has joined her right to His own and said: “Give thanks to Me and to your parents; to Me is the final return.”
Sources of Shi‘i Jurisprudence (translation of جامع أحادیث الشیعه), vol. 26, p. 892
It is also related from Imam al-Sadiq (AS): A man may be undutiful to his parents during their lifetime, yet after their death fast and pray on their behalf, repay their debts, and continue doing so until he is recorded among the dutiful. Conversely, he may be dutiful to them while they are alive, but after they die fail to repay their debts or do them any good, and persist in this until he is recorded among the undutiful.
The Etiquette of Social Relations (translation of volumes 71 and 72 of بحار الأنوار), vol. 1, p. 54.