Regarding the question raised, the religious authorities have expressed different views on this ruling. Some, such as Ayatollah Makarem (may God preserve him), have said that if one is unsure, one may consume it and then pay khums on that amount later. Others, such as Ayatollah Sistani, if I remember correctly, have said that the homeowner is liable, and so on. There are differing opinions. Does this hadith—that it is better to refrain from doubtful matters—take precedence over the fatwas of the religious authorities?
Does the hadith «الوقوف عند الشبهة خیر من الاقتحام فی الهلکة» take precedence over the fatwas of the religious authorities?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
When something is doubtful, and there is no necessity or emergency, refraining from it is better than risking ruin. An act may carry no punishment under certain circumstances, but the question of drawing closer to the Beloved and directing one’s desires towards Him is distinct from the question of Paradise and Hell. It is therefore preferable to choose what is best and to incline towards it.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterMy Lord, do not let any food that distances me from You enter my stomach.
The point is to choose what is best. When there is no necessity or emergency, how beautiful it is to do what is best—and thereby become one who does good!
Under certain circumstances, an action may carry no punishment. But drawing near to the Beloved and awakening a longing and love for Him is a matter distinct from Paradise and Hell.