Greetings to our dear teacher and respected friends,
Someone who has no religious beliefs has asked:
“You tell me where you were before you were born, and I’ll tell you where you’ll go after you die.”
What can we say in response?
How to Answer a Nonbeliever’s Question About Life Before Birth and After Death
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Before birth, the soul existed in another realm, where it acquired experiences and traits that influence a person’s behaviour and character in this world. A child is born knowing how to cry and seeking familiarity—signs of a previous life. Death, too, marks the beginning of a new life, and reason tells us not to trade the eternal abode for this fleeting world.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center_Page_One
This is the easiest question to answer with evidence from the Qur’an, the narrations and reason. But since he has no belief in religion, his question must be answered by rational arguments alone—and he, too, must accept the truth without obstinacy or resistance.
There are certainly people who possess faculties beyond the five senses. They see and hear, and experience particular perceptions and sensations that others cannot. For those deprived of such perceptions to deny them is like blind people denying the existence of all things visible—colours, light, beauty and scenery. So if the questioner rejects the answer to this question, there is no reason to be surprised!
A child is born with particular feelings and perceptions that point to their having been acquired in another world.
A newborn already knows how to cry and seek familiarity. Despite its physical helplessness, it has particular spiritual and psychological capacities for expressing its feelings and communicating its wants and needs, and makes excellent use of them.
A child’s senses are active at their own level, and the child makes use of them. The brain processes the information they provide, ultimately giving rise to a particular perception and understanding. Yet a newborn’s ultimate perception has nothing to do with its brain or physical faculties; it operates independently. This inner faculty was trained in a world beyond the earthly realm. It was taught there, in a realm that exists independently and precedes this world.
Children raised in the same environment and under the same conditions of education nevertheless differ in character and behaviour. This suggests that their earthly lives derive from a life before this world—a life in which they lived as spirits, gathered experience and acquired dispositions, which they now draw upon in the streets and marketplaces of this world!
So before this earthly realm, we passed through the world of the heart, the world of spirituality, and the world of souls!
To discover truths, understand questions, and make discoveries and inventions, everyone needs an inner intuition, sometimes called a hypothesis. In effect, one prepares the heart to receive an answer from another world: a kind of communication between the heart and a higher realm.
To be continued
#Answer2167_Page_Two
Before this world, I tasted love in the world of love, acquired its knowledge and reached its sources. There I came to know my mother and father, and others!
Before this world, in the realm of pure knowledge, I drank in the light of learning; after entering this world, I followed its path with a mind steeped in knowledge.
We brought genius with us into this world as a gift!
I am an emigrant from the world of knowledge and reason. I brought the seeds of knowledge from that world into this one, planted them in the soil of my mind and thought, and nurtured them.
The different layers of my brain, and my hidden and outward senses, show that I have passed through other realms and finally arrived in this world!
To be continued
#Answer2167_Page_Three
A newborn laughs and feels fear; it becomes happy and sad, even though in most cases no material cause is involved. Surely, before this earthly realm, we lived in a world where we learned and experienced joy and sorrow, and made them part of our very being!
A newborn dreams, too. What does it see? Whatever it may be, the child reacts—suggesting that it is meeting a land where it once lived, and has now travelled there in a dream to meet its inhabitants!
To be continued!
#Answer2167_Page_Four
I came into this world with a particular order, system and structure. In other words, I opened my eyes to the world with a complex constitution in whose bodily and inner workings I had no hand. Surely, I acquired such a craft in the world of «صنعه الصنایع»; and when I migrate from this world, I will enter a higher, transcendent world governed by an even more complex order!
Whatever I may deny, I cannot deny my birth and death. I have an origin and a return, and ultimately, with my death, my life in this world will mark the beginning of a new life! Reason dictates that I should not sacrifice the everlasting abode for the sake of this fleeting world.
I implore you: use your reason and reflect!