Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
login Login
Philosophy and Logic 31 August 2022 Reading time: 1 min

If we deny attributes of the Divine Essence, does that denial itself impose a limitation on God?

Author: Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) • Soroush-e Bamdadan Cultural Center • Read 28 times
If we deny attributes of the Divine Essence, does that denial itself impose a limitation on God?

«To deny attributes of the Divine Essence is simply to deny the attributes themselves and what they entail. Priority and finality are denied of the Divine Essence so that God’s supremacy over them may be affirmed. This does not imply any limitation of the Divine Essence; rather, it underscores God’s transcendence beyond every attribute and description.»

Question: If we accept the denial of attributes in the case of the Divine Essence, then, when denying priority and finality of His Essence—qualities regarded as His attributes—are we not, God forbid, affirming that the Divine Essence is limited?

The discussion concerns denying attributes of the Divine Essence, not denying the attributes themselves alone while retaining what they entail.

In creating time, the Creator of existence affirmed what is beyond time and denied priority in the sense of having a beginning. Alongside this, the attributes of First and Last are denied of the Divine Essence, while His supremacy over priority is affirmed.

Any necessary connection between creation and created things—even an incidental one—is incompatible with the pre-eternity of the Divine Essence. Allah truly created all things from nothing.

The Divine Essence is exalted above every description and act of describing, and is itself free of any attribute.

Denying attributes and all their instances is a condition for complete sincerity in affirming God’s oneness. ضَلَّتْ فِيكَ الصِّفَاتُ، وَ تَفَسَّخَتْ دُونَكَ النُّعُوتُ، وَ حَارَتْ فِي كِبْرِيَائِكَ لَطَائِفُ الْأَوْهَام‏

A
✓

Master Ali Saei

(Abdullah Meshkat) Researcher and commentator on Shi‘i wisdom and the foundations of divine unity

A researcher specializing in religious studies and divine unity, with a particular focus on the Qur’an and Hadith (the Two Weighty Things). His research has centered primarily on the Qur’an and Hadith; in recent years, he has also explored divine unity and critiques of philosophical viewpoints.

Was this research essay and article helpful and illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.

Analytical comments and annotations on this article

If any part of this response is unclear, please submit your question so it may be addressed by the teacher after review.

0 entries submitted
To submit a question, please register or log in to your account. Responses to your inquiries will also be recorded in your personal dashboard.
Login / Register via SMS

No inquiries have been recorded regarding this response yet. Your perspective or question will be the first.

Explore Related Topics and the Atlas of Knowledge

Research and Thematic Guidance within the Intellectual Framework and Inquiries of the Meshkat-e Noor School

View Full Hierarchy