Peace be upon you. May God give you strength, teacher. What should the basis for classifying the sciences be, and what is the right basis for doing so? Why, in fact, have the sciences become separate fragments? Don’t all the sciences share a single root?
What Is the Basis for Classifying the Sciences, and Why Have They Become Fragmented?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Knowledge is a single light with many branches, all harmoniously connected as a whole. The sciences become fragmented when they are no longer guided by reason and become mixed with ignorance. Much of what passes for science today is ignorance dressed up as knowledge, narrowing the path of devotion to God and losing its unity.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterKnowledge is a single light with many rays and branches. All its branches are the boughs, leaves and fruits of one tree’s root: the various sciences are meant to complement and harmonise with one another, united and integrated. But when reason fails to guide knowledge, it fragments, loses its unity, and, mingled with ignorance, adds to the darkness instead of dispelling it.
Indeed, much of what is called knowledge today is, in reality, ignorance wearing only a thin veneer of learning. One need only observe that, instead of widening the path of devotion, it makes the way of worship and servitude narrower.