Can this argument be accepted—that one of the reasons Hazrat Zahra (SA) went behind the door in the incident of the burning of the door of the Commander of the Faithful's (AS) house was that a woman could not be the cause of a war or an uprising, and otherwise the Lady herself or the Imam's companions would have been the first to open the door?
Did Hazrat Zahra (SA) Go Behind the Door to Prevent a Fight?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The raid on the house of the Commander of the Faithful (AS) was sudden and took them by surprise. After the Master was seized, Hazrat Zahra (SA) acted to defend him and was wounded at this stage. The argument that she went behind the door to prevent a fight is not acceptable, given the surprise nature of the attack and the injuries inflicted; for the attackers entered the house by trickery and plotting in order to take the Master unawares.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterA careful scholarly examination suggests that the assault on the house was sudden.
Because the violation of the threshold of the Master, the Commander of the Faithful علیه السلام, was such a grave matter, the attackers repeatedly reported each development to Abu Bakr and sought instructions on how to proceed in the new circumstances. It is therefore plausible that their assault on the Master’s house was sudden, covert, and intended to take its occupants by surprise—like a night raid.
Lady Fatima al-Zahra سلام الله علیها was wounded on several occasions. The assault itself was sudden and took them by surprise. It seems the attackers entered the house abruptly and swiftly, through deceit and scheming, because they knew that if the Master reacted, no one would be able to stop him. They had therefore devised a plan to seize him by surprise.
The sudden, surprise assault left the Master unable to take up his sword in self-defence. The partisans of Saqifa entered the Master’s home in a manner contrary to Arab custom and without honour. After they had seized the Master and the Lady had come to his defence, she was dealt a more grievous wound.