Does the knowledge of angels and messengers belong to the stage after the decree is ratified? The following hadith seems to indicate that badāʾ does not occur in the knowledge imparted to angels and messengers, since otherwise God—God forbid—would be a liar:
إن علیا ع کان یقول العلم علمان فعلم علمه الله ملائکته و رسله فما علمه ملائکته و رسله فإنه یکون و لا یکذب نفسه و لا ملائکته و لا رسله و علم عنده مخزون لم یطلع علیه أحدا من خلقه یقدم منه ما یشاء و یؤخر منه ما یشاء و یمحو ما یشاء
Does the Knowledge of Angels and Messengers Belong to the Stage After the Decree Is Ratified?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The knowledge given to angels and messengers is part of God’s bestowed knowledge, which is limited and does not encompass divine badāʾ. God’s withheld knowledge, which belongs to the Exalted Essence, encompasses bestowed knowledge, and badāʾ does not occur within it. This means that God’s knowledge encompasses the knowledge of angels and prophets.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThis hadith points to the limits of the angels’ knowledge, not its comprehensiveness!
It indicates that the angels have no knowledge of divine badāʾ.
Nor does it prove that God does not bring about badāʾ in matters known to the angels. This follows naturally from the fact that divine knowledge encompasses and contains the angels’ knowledge.
عن أبی جعفر ع قال سمعته یقول إن لله علمین علم مبذول و علم مکفوف فأما المبذول فإنه لیس من شیء یعلمه الملائکه و الرسل إلا و نحن نعلمه و أما المکفوف فهو الذی عنده فی أم الکتاب إذا خرج نفذ.
بصائر الدرجات فی فضائل آل محمد صلى الله علیهم، ج1، ص: 109
“God—Mighty and Exalted—is possessed of two kinds of knowledge: knowledge bestowed on others, and knowledge withheld, belonging uniquely to the Divine Essence. As for the knowledge bestowed, everything made known to all the angels and prophets has also been made known to us. As for the knowledge withheld, it is with God; when it manifests, it comes to pass.”
Let us bear in mind that God’s withheld knowledge encompasses His bestowed knowledge!
Allah knows best!