You said that obedience is desirable only when accompanied by affirmation and certainty; otherwise, it has no value. Surely, once we have found the truth, we must follow it—and this does not conflict with human freedom, since we can choose not to do so. Yet to bear witness to our covenant of servitude, we must follow the truth.
⁉ How can we attain the station of affirmation and certainty?
Is it enough simply to believe that God is All-Knowing, Wise, Just, and so on? Does this mean we should say that whatever God has ordained must therefore be good? Or should we seek evidence, reflect, investigate, and so forth, until the matter is established with certainty and we attain the station of affirmation?
⁉ Secondly, what should we do to find the truth?
#Answer 1753
Affirmation is, in fact, certainty refined to its highest degree. It is a soldier in the army of reason, one we must choose and give a place in our hearts. Sound choice is possible only with a pure heart. Once we have chosen what is best, we must firmly establish in our hearts the place of this exalted divine power. To strengthen the station of truthfulness, we must set out on the road of Islam toward the abode of truthfulness.
When we reach the lofty station of certainty, the light of truthfulness will become manifest. So we must strengthen the four pillars of certainty:
فالیقین منه على أربع شعب على الشوق و الشفق و الزهد و الترقب فمن اشتاق إلى الجنه سلا عن الشهوات و من أشفق من النار اتقى المحرمات و من زهد فی الدنیا هانت علیه المصیبات و من ارتقب الموت سارع فی الخیرات
Certainty, too, rests on four pillars: keen insight, discerning understanding of realities, learning lessons from the events of the age, and following the sound path of those who came before. Whoever looks at realities with keen intelligence sees wisdom clearly; whoever sees wisdom clearly recognizes the value of taking lessons; and whoever recognizes the value of taking lessons is, as it were, living among those who have passed before.
Nahj al-Balagha, trans. Dashti, p. 629.
قال الصادق ع الصدق نور متشعشع فی عالمه کالشمس یستضیء بها کل شیء بمعناها من غیر نقصان یقع على معناها
مصباح الشریعه، ص: 34
Imam al-Sadiq (AS) said: “Truth is a radiant light in the realm of meaning, like the sun, by which everything is illumined through its light, without the sun’s radiance being diminished in any way.”
و قال أمیر المؤمنین ع الصدق سیف الله فی أرضه و سمائه أینما هوى به یقده فإذا أردت أن تعلم أ صادق أنت أم کاذب فانظر فی صدق معناک و عقد دعواک و عیرهما بقسطاس من الله تعالى کأنک فی القیامه قال الله تعالى و الوزن یومئذ الحق فإذا اعتدل معناک بغور دعواک ثبت لک الصدق و أدنى حد الصدق أن لا یخالف اللسان القلب و لا القلب اللسان و مثل الصادق الموصوف بما ذکرنا کمثل النازع لروحه إن لم ینزع فما ذا یصنع
مصباح الشریعه، ص: 34
Imam Ali (AS) said: “Truth is God’s sword on earth and in heaven. Wherever it falls, it cuts through.” So if you wish to know whether you are truthful or false, examine the truth of your inward meaning and the substance of your claims with utmost care, weighing them on God Almighty’s scales of justice—as though you stood before Him on the Day of Resurrection. God Almighty says: «وَٱلْوَزْنُ يَوْمَئِذٍ ٱلْحَقُّ»—“On that Day, the weighing will be just.” When your inward meaning accords with the depth of your claims, truthfulness will be established in you. The very least degree of truthfulness is that the tongue does not contradict the heart, nor the heart the tongue; that inner conviction and outward expression agree.
A truthful person, as we have described, is like someone whose soul is being drawn from his body. One who is at the point of death must turn toward the spiritual realm and leave behind the world of matter and appearances. So, too, the truthful person follows truth and integrity in all his states, words and thoughts, and leaves behind pretence, contradiction, empty claims and the pursuit of people’s desires.
Misbah al-Shari'ah / translated by Mostafavi, text, p. 327
قال أمیر المؤمنین ع لأنسبن الإسلام نسبه لا ینسبه أحد قبلی و لا ینسبه أحد بعدی إلا بمثل ذلک إن الإسلام هو التسلیم و التسلیم هو الیقین و الیقین هو التصدیق و التصدیق هو الإقرار و الإقرار هو العمل و العمل هو الأداء- إن المؤمن لم یأخذ دینه عن رأیه و لکن أتاه من ربه فأخذه إن المؤمن یرى یقینه فی عمله و الکافر یرى إنکاره فی عمله فو الذی نفسی بیده ما عرفوا أمرهم فاعتبروا إنکار الکافرین و المنافقین بأعمالهم الخبیثه.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج2، ص: 45
Imam Ali (AS) said: “I shall define Islam in a way that no one before me or after me will define it, except by expressing the same meaning. Islam is submission; submission is certainty; certainty is affirmation; affirmation is acknowledgment; acknowledgment is action; and action is the fulfilment of what is required.
“A believer has not acquired his religion through his own opinion. Rather, it has come to him from his Lord, and he has received it. The believer’s certainty is reflected in his actions, and the unbeliever’s denial is reflected in his actions. By the One in whose hand is my soul, they did not understand their own affairs. So take heed from the unbelievers’ and hypocrites’ denial as shown by their evil deeds.”
Usul al-Kafi / translated by Kamare'i, vol. 4, p. 150.