Hello, teacher. How can we prove the Resurrection, and that the soul survives after death, to someone with a materialist outlook who believes that we perish after death?
How Can We Prove the Resurrection to Materialists?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
To prove the Resurrection to materialists, one could argue that without it, the universe would be reduced to scattered elements that cannot cease to exist. If we suppose that they do cease to exist, then there must be something that annihilates them—which in itself proves the existence of a Creator and the possibility of bringing life back. This process would continue forever, thereby proving eternity in its own right.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center+ 2
Suppose there is no afterlife. What would become of the universe? Suppose, further, that everything died. What would remain? Would it be nothing but a handful of elements—scattered protons and electrons? And what would become of these fundamental particles when they died? If we say they would cease to exist, the question arises: how? For, according to our ordinary understanding, it is impossible for them to cease to exist. This process would then continue forever, thereby establishing eternity of its own accord. But if we say that it is possible for them to cease to exist, then there must necessarily be an agent that brings about their annihilation. And once again, it follows that a creator brought life into being from nothing; that same creator will bring it to life again.