Is this argument valid?
Every person, upon reading any philosophical book, will form their own personal interpretation of its contents—so how, then, is the author's intent to be understood?
Did the author not write the book in order to convey his own beliefs and convictions to the reader?
If every reader is to have their own personal interpretation, then who will understand the author's intent?
How Can We Understand the Author’s Intent in a Philosophical Book?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
To understand the author's intent in a philosophical book, both the author must be careful in how he arranges his expressions and the reader must possess the necessary scholarly ability. Entering into philosophical discussions without intellectual and scholarly preparation is dangerous, and only researchers are capable of undertaking it. Intellectual and spiritual soundness prepares the ground for rational reflection and for distinguishing the genuine from the spurious.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIn writing a book, an author must take care to arrange his words precisely, ensuring that the material is sound and academically reliable. Readers, too, should approach philosophical propositions only when confident in their ability to understand them.
Just as not every food is fit to eat, not every subject is fit to read. Only scholars and researchers are equipped to engage with every philosophical question. Anyone who does so without first considering their intellectual and scholarly capacity must reckon with the dangerous consequences. A sound intellect and an inner spiritual life shaped by ethics open the way to reasoned reflection—the key to discerning what is genuine from what is false.
The Master Designer of creation has placed the path to drawing upon human nature, which reveals the truth, upon the straight path. Whoever strays from it will, without doubt, fall into the abyss of corrupt beliefs.