In what manner does creation emanate from the First Emanated Being? Please advise. Thank you.
How Does Creation Emanate from the First Emanated Being?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The philosophical discussion of the First Emanation faces difficulties such as the principle of affinity between cause and effect and its apparent conflict with divine oneness. The Divine Essence lies beyond the grasp of created beings, and the manner of creation is regarded as one of the divine mysteries. These views conflict with the oneness of the Divine Essence and the created nature of all things.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe discussion opened in philosophy under the heading of the “First Emanation” has certain fundamental problems. It is problematic both scientifically and logically, and it is also in direct conflict with the reality of the Creator and the created. Its proponents maintain that cause and effect belong to the same kind—a view in outright conflict with the very foundation of divine unity!
They maintain that cause and effect are one in kind and must share an essential likeness. This is in obvious conflict, both rationally and religiously, with the true order of divine unity. In the case of the Creator, an effect has no relation to Him other than being created. If someone maintains that the two are of the same kind, then necessarily they must be so in every respect; that is, cause and effect would be wholly equal. Moreover, a single essence cannot have different aspects, since that would entail dividing the essence, which conflicts with the principle of unity.
Being of the same kind means being two. And whenever there is a second entity like a single, unique essence, both entities will be incomplete, each with its own limits and boundaries. In other words, both will be limited and subject to constraint!
The basis for raising this issue is the principle «الواحد لا یصدر عنه الا الواحد». They hold that something one in every respect cannot give rise to multiple, diverse effects. The root of this error lies in their manifest ignorance and mistaken assumption that, in creation, something issues or emerges from the Creator’s essence—as though the Creator were made up of parts, one of which emerged, and that part had to be one with the essence. Since, on the one hand, they maintain that the essence is infinite and one, while, on the other, they imagine that creation would compromise this unity, they conclude that the First Emanation must be one. In reality, this makes the First Emanation identical with the Essence of the Real!
The obvious flaw in this way of thinking is that if there were another one alongside the One, both would cease to be one. From another perspective, if the First Emanation is one, it must be the very same as the First One—that is, itself. If the First Emanation is the same as the One Essence, then nothing has in fact emanated at all. That would be the most meaningless argument imaginable!
Some philosophers do not understand that the sphere in which creatures operate ends with the world of creatures; they cannot go beyond it. What has the Essence of the Real to do with the vision and thought of a created being?!!! The Essence of the Real cannot be described. Moreover, how creation takes place, creation itself, and the existence of God’s creatures are among the mysteries that no thought has ever managed to uncover or comprehend. The Creator is beyond the secret of secrets, higher than the unseen of the unseen!
The truth is that the Creator brought creatures into being and made His first creation the means by which He brought His other creatures into being. This does not mean that the Creator could not create each creature separately. And, from another perspective, how do we know that the Creator did not bring about different forms of creation, while we are simply incapable of gaining even a partial understanding of this creation in more than one form and remain unaware of the diversity of creation brought about by the All-Knowing Creator?
«قال أمیر المؤمنین ع: إن الله تبارک و تعالى أحد واحد، تفرد فی وحدانیته، ثم تکلم بکلمه فصارت نورا، ثم خلق من ذلک النور محمدا ص و خلقنی و ذریتی،
A Brief Guide to Insights, p. 130
Continuation of #Response1510
Please point out what you find unconvincing!
A created being’s capacity for understanding is confined to the sphere of its own creation and cannot extend beyond it. To understand how the Creator relates to the created, one would have to enter the Creator’s sphere—and that would amount to the annihilation of the created, since a created being can rise no higher than its own stature!
Hello, and thank you for all your efforts. Could we say, then, that each prophet’s existential capacity is manifested in his book?
Completion of #Response1510
Every heavenly book has multiple inner meanings, mysteries, forms, interpretations, and modes of revelation. It is possible that only a few sparks from a heavenly book were kindled in the heart of each prophet, while its unseen flashes remained. Therefore, it may be said that measuring each prophet by the heavenly book revealed to him is not sound.
My question is about how creation began. God existed, and nothing else did. Then creation began. How did it begin?
Supplement to #Response1510
Our inability to explain how creation came forth from the Creator of existence, or how created things relate to their Creator, does not mean that we must strain ourselves to explain, describe, and account for the bringing of creatures into being by the Real. The sweetest explanation is to acknowledge our ignorance. We are created and confined by the limits of our own creation; any attempt to trespass into the precinct of divine majesty will bring us nothing but the burning of the wings of thought and reason. We struggle even to understand how one created thing relates to another, or how a part relates to a whole and one particle to another. Given our profound lack of knowledge, is it right for us to address how the Creator relates to the created? To be created is, by its very nature, to be in relation; God is the One who relates all existence, and He is supreme, all-subduing, and encompassing all creatures.
What is your evidence?
Hello, and thank you for all your efforts. Could we say, then, that each prophet’s existential capacity is manifested in his book?
Explanation of Response1510
Aal Imran 3:48: و یعلمه الکتاب و الحکمه و التوراه و الإنجیل
“And He will teach him the Book, wisdom, the Torah, and the Gospel.”
What is meant by teaching him the Book, wisdom, the Torah, and the Gospel is not their outward wording!!!