Is the book *The Wives of the Messenger of God, Mothers of the Believers*, by Amirhasan Khanji, accepted by Shiites? The book does cite some sources and makes a number of claims that seem unworthy of the Prophet (PBUH).
Is the book *The Wives of the Messenger of God, Mothers of the Believers* accepted by Shiites?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The book *The Wives of the Messenger of God, Mothers of the Believers*, by Amirhasan Khanji, is not accepted by Shiites. Because it insults the Prophet (PBUH) and his wives, especially Lady Khadija (SA), and relies on unsourced material, the book is wholly unfair and hostile toward Islam.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterO God, break the pens of the ignorant.
This book should be called “A Book of Insults.” Injustice runs rampant throughout it. Its very foundation is made up of unreliable sources. Khadija سلام الله علیها is portrayed in a deeply inadequate way, and false allegations are made against her. The other wives of the pure and noble Prophet are likewise presented from the perspective of hostile, ignorant people. And in its treatment of Aisha, it even hurls vile insults at the Prophet of Light—nothing but sheer lies!
Truly, it pains the heart. When one comes across such things, death itself seems more appealing. It is impossible to know what grudge they bear against the Messenger of Mercy, that they should set out to oppose the Beloved of the Lord of the Worlds in this way, with such brazen insolence!
Truly, this is cause for mourning! May these books be enough to wound and grieve the Mahdi عج—what agonies must he endure!
O God, make the pens that have become spears of hatred in the hands of the tyrants and ignoramuses of our time, aimed at the very heart of religion, a burden upon their necks; and break their pens, inkwells, and pen-holding hands all at once!
O God, we beseech You by the tender heart of the Mahdi علیه السلام: do not spare them. Before their destruction, expose them in this very world!
یا مهدی عج آجرک الله!