Respected teacher, when we are harmed and mistreated by someone, and this distress over that person leads us to recount our distress over them to others and thereby find a little relief, does this count as backbiting? And if it is backbiting, please advise us how we can control this distress of ours, so that we are both safeguarded from its spiritual harms and not fall into the sin of backbiting. Thank you.
Is Voicing One’s Distress at Being Harmed by Others Considered Backbiting?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Voicing one's distress at being harmed and mistreated by others in order to find peace is not considered backbiting, provided it is done with the intention of reform and remedy, and the person one speaks to is a reformer and a physician. But the best way to heal the pain caused by others' mistreatment is to complain to God, the Exalted, from the depths of one's heart. Solitude with the Beloved and voicing one's complaints is the path of goodly communion with God.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterApart from permissible forms of backbiting, a person’s motive does not change the nature of the backbiting itself, though it may add to the sum of their misdeeds. When someone feels there is no choice but to recount what a particular person has done, and that the pain caused by this person can be soothed only by telling someone about it, the person they confide in should surely be a peacemaker, like a physician who treats an ailment.
The best way to heal the pain caused by others is to pour out your heart’s grievance before حضرت «سمیع الدعاء». Be alone with your Lord and tell the All-Knowing God what is in your heart and what troubles you about that person. Though He knows the innermost thoughts of the heart and the deeds of His servants, confiding your heart’s grievance is a beautiful way to draw near to the One God.