If Imam Husayn (AS) knew that Ali al-Asghar would be struck by an arrow, then he would have had a hand in his death. So long as we exaggerate the knowledge of the Infallible, these historical difficulties will remain unresolved.
#پاسخ2549_برگ_دوم
Did Abraham (AS) know that the knife would cut when he took Ishmael (AS) to the place of sacrifice? And did Ishmael (AS) know that he was going to the place of sacrifice and would be slaughtered? If so, why did they go?!
The answer is simple!
Abraham (AS) took Ishmael (AS) to the place of sacrifice in order to carry out God’s command and affirm the truth of servitude to God. Had Ishmael (AS) been killed, he would have been a martyr, and Abraham (AS) a fighter in the way of God!
In any case, Abraham (AS) set out for the place of sacrifice intending to kill, and Ishmael (AS) intending to be killed in the way of God!
الصافات : 102 فلما بلغ معه السعی قال یا بنی إنی أرى فی المنام أنی أذبحک فانظر ما ذا ترى قال یا أبت افعل ما تؤمر ستجدنی إن شاء الله من الصابرین
When he had grown old enough to work alongside him, Abraham said, “My son, I have seen in a dream that I am to sacrifice you. Consider, then, what you think.” He replied, “My father, do as you are commanded. God willing, you will find me among the steadfast.”
Imam Husayn (AS) was the Imam of his time. Guided by the light of his Imamate and guardianship, he acted rightly and chose the most beautiful self-sacrifice to revive God’s religion. And yet he took the most beautiful and tender offering in the world to the place of sacrifice!
Certainly, Imam Husayn (AS) did not take Ali al-Asghar (AS) into the midst of Yazid’s army so that he might be martyred; rather, in the depths of his merciful heart, he was prepared to accept the child’s martyrdom!
If the Messenger of God صلی الله علیه و آله و سلم was the City of Knowledge, and the Mawla (AS) its Gate, and the other Imams (AS) the gates of that same city, then how is the Gate itself connected to knowledge when one enters the land of knowledge through the Gate of Knowledge?! We must broaden our path to understanding the Imams (AS), so that we do not doubt their knowledge!
A life returned to its Owner is not a transaction of death, but of becoming more alive!
The purpose of creation is the manifestation of servitude to God. Giving one’s life in the way of the One who owns it is the highest expression of servitude to God!
البقره : 207 و من الناس من یشری نفسه ابتغاء مرضات الله و الله رؤف بالعباد
Some people—believers who are ready to sacrifice themselves, like Ali (AS) when he slept in the Prophet’s place on the Night of the Migration—sell their lives in pursuit of God’s pleasure. God is Most Kind to His servants.
Imam Husayn (AS) made a bargain with God, offering his life, his possessions and his children! What a bargain!
التوبه : 111 إن الله اشترى من المؤمنین أنفسهم و أموالهم بأن لهم الجنه یقاتلون فی سبیل الله فیقتلون و یقتلون وعدا علیه حقا فی التوراه و الإنجیل و القرآن و من أوفى بعهده من الله فاستبشروا ببیعکم الذی بایعتم به و ذلک هو الفوز العظیم
God has purchased from the believers their lives and their possessions in exchange for Paradise. They fight in the way of God, killing and being killed. This is a true promise binding on Him, recorded in the Torah, the Gospel and the Quran. And who is more faithful to His promise than God? So rejoice in the bargain you have made with Him. That is the supreme triumph.
This was a truth even Pharaoh’s magicians understood: they did not enter into a bargain with Pharaoh by sharing in their own deaths; instead, they made their bargain with the One and Only God!
الأعراف : 125 قالوا إنا إلى ربنا منقلبون
They said, “We are returning to our Lord!”