Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
login Login
category محور بنیادین از سند جامع معارف پژوهش‌های عقلی، کلامی، فلسفی و سلوکی

Jurisprudence and Rulings

بازخوانی خردورزانه مبانی معرفتی، حکمت، کلام و معارف شیعی با تکیه بر سنت عقلانی و پاسخ‌گویی به پرسش‌ها و شبهات نوپدید فکری در پرتو آثار و مباحث استاد علی ساعی (عبدالله مشکات).

مجموع پرسش‌های کهف 34
جلسات صوتی ضبط‌شده 3
ویدیوها و نماهنگ‌ها 4
مقالات پژوهشی عمیق 1
psychology
شارح و استاد محوری Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

شما می‌توانید با پیگیری این دسته‌بندی، از انتشار آخرین جلسات صوتی و پاسخ‌های جدید در حوزه {topic} مطلع شوید.

rss_feed
expand_more
Question code: 36477
10 September 2026

How Do Buying Wheat, Flour, and Bread Affect One’s Wealth and Blessings?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

A hadith from Imam al-Kazim (AS) states that buying wheat increases one’s wealth, buying flour halves it, and buying bread causes it to be lost. The hadith points to the health, economic, spiritual, and psychological dimensions of buying each of these items, and locates blessing in preserving the integrity of food, self-sufficiency, and a spiritual connection with the Creator.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36470
10 September 2026

Is It Valid to Reduce or Increase the Amount Vowed for Imam Hussein?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

A vow must be fulfilled according to the intention, time, place, and amount specified when it was made. If an emergency prevents this, the vow may be fulfilled once the situation has passed. If the appointed time has gone by, the vow remains due for the following year. Without a valid reason, reducing or increasing the amount, or changing the time, is not permissible.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36458
10 September 2026

When During the Day and Night Is There Greater Emphasis on Being in a State of Ablution?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Ablution is recommended and preferable at all times, but special emphasis is placed on being in a state of ablution when reciting the Quran, praying and supplicating, going to sleep or eating, visiting holy sites, entering a mosque, and in the hours before dawn.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36452
10 September 2026

Can Persistent Prayer for Others Make Amends for Violating Their Rights?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

A person’s rights are not discharged except by making amends and obtaining their forgiveness. But if someone is unable to repay what is owed, God, the Absolutely Self-Sufficient, may make restitution on their behalf—provided they have fulfilled all the requirements of repentance. Taking a careless attitude toward the rights of others deprives a person of the grace to repent and the opportunity to make amends.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36448
10 September 2026

What Is the Rationale for Zakat on Livestock, and Why Is There No Obligatory Zakat on Cars?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The rationale for zakat on livestock—cattle, sheep, and camels—is not easy to explain. In general, however, zakat is an act of worship that purifies and increases one’s wealth. These animals benefit not only their owners in material ways but society as well. Wealth that does not fall into one of the nine prescribed categories is subject to khums, not obligatory zakat.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36444
10 September 2026

How Does the Influence of Unlawful Earnings Become Evident in One’s Descendants?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

A pure spirit is breathed into a pure seed, and an impure spirit into an impure seed. The harmful effects of unlawful earnings are not confined to the seed; they also affect a person’s constitution and character, and become visible in outward appearance. A tendency toward base behavior and an insatiable appetite for sin are among the signs of the consequences of consuming what is unlawful.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36445
10 September 2026

How Can One Repent for Unlawful Earnings and Their Effects on Future Generations?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Sincere repentance and making amends for unlawful earnings purify a person. Any impurity in their children is their own responsibility; the parent has merely provided the means by which it may have been passed on. If someone has raised children for years on unlawful earnings and then repents, sincere repentance and making amends will purify them.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36423
10 September 2026

Is It Shirk to Ask Others for Help?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

There is nothing wrong with turning to others for help with our ordinary worldly needs, provided we understand that they are means through which things come about and are themselves in need of God. Asking them for help must not become worship or supplication; we should recognise the limits of their abilities and not regard them as healers in their own right.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36424
10 September 2026

What Is the Relationship Between the Authority of the Jurist and the Authority of the Infallible Imam?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The just and most learned jurist is a radiant light of the Qur’an and the Prophet’s Household, and a voice for the Two Weighty Things. So long as he upholds this station and meets the standards of superior knowledge and sound judgment, the authority of God’s proof remains a shelter for all people, and obedience to him is obligatory.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36426
10 September 2026

How Can We Identify the Most Learned and Best-Qualified Jurist?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Recognising the most learned and best-qualified jurist, like believing in the prophets and the revealed scriptures, is something inspired in a person through their innate disposition and relationship with God. This recognition comes through sincere seeking and striving in the cause of truth, and God shows the paths of guidance to those who do good.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36394
10 September 2026

What is the difference between reciting al-Fātiḥa for a particular deceased person and for all the deceased?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

After remembering a particular deceased person, it is better also to offer a general prayer for all deceased believers, so that the reward reaches everyone without diminishing the reward of the person specifically remembered. Prayers such as «اللهم و اعمم بذلک من شهد لک بالربوبیة...» are recommended for this purpose.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36383
10 September 2026

What Is the Connection Between Urinating in the Bathroom and a Lack of Blessing in One’s Life?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

According to a narration from Imam Ali (AS), urinating in the bathroom is one of the factors associated with a lack of blessing and poverty in life. The narration also mentions other causes of poverty, such as leaving cobwebs in the home and eating while in a state of major ritual impurity. Other narrations, meanwhile, point to ways of increasing one’s provision, including maintaining family ties and seeking forgiveness.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36369
10 September 2026

What is the duty toward those who remove their hijab in the name of opposing the system?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Those who remove their hijab in the name of opposing the system, or appear naked in public, fall into a category of disbelief, and their actions must be disavowed. Under certain conditions, the duty to enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong must not be neglected in dealing with them. In this context, disbelief means abandoning God’s commands and committing what He has forbidden.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36359
10 September 2026

How Sound Are the Hadiths About Writing the Qur’an and Drinking It for Healing?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Reports describe writing Qur’anic passages and drinking them for healing, but these practices are said to involve particular principles and mysteries and to require expertise. God is the true Healer; no remedy can be effective without His permission. The Qur’an itself is a healing for what is in the hearts, and a guidance and mercy for the believers.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36352
10 September 2026

What Is the Status in Shi‘i Jurisprudence of Someone Who Rejects General Deputyship?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Someone who rejects general deputyship rejects God’s ruling, because the one who derives rulings from the Ahl al-Bayt (AS) gives voice to their unspoken traditions, and his ruling carries the authority of God’s ruling. Anyone who turns away from certainty and chooses denial has rejected God’s ruling.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36356
10 September 2026

How Is Ghusl Different from Bathing? Why Does It Require a Specific Intention and Order?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Ghusl is different from bathing: it is performed to attain ritual purity before God and requires an intention and a specific order prescribed by Him. Just as provision and healing come by God’s permission, purity too is attained only by following His laws and with His permission. The intention and order in ghusl are essential elements; without them, ritual purity is not achieved.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36347
10 September 2026

What Does Sūrat al-Naḥl, Verse 67, Say About Intoxicating Drink?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Sūrat al-Naḥl, verse 67, refers to how people make use of dates and grapes: they can produce both intoxicating drinks and wholesome food. Like the tongue, which may be used for good or ill, this is a sign for those who reflect. However, the verse was abrogated when the prohibition of wine was revealed.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36332
10 September 2026

Are Gold and Other Assets Subject to Khums and Zakat?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The conditions for paying khums and zakat are clearly defined. Changing or converting property on which khums or zakat has not been paid does not remove the obligation. Whether someone is required to pay khums or zakat should be determined by a religious authority or through the person’s own ijtihad; they may be exempt, or even eligible for assistance.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36335
10 September 2026

Is Sending Blessings on the Prophet a Prayer That Requires No Ablution?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Sending blessings upon the Prophet and his family is a special form of prayer that, like the funeral prayer, does not require ablution. It is the finest way to remember the Lord and is considered a form of worship. This hadith is reported in al-Tabarsi’s *al-Ihtijāj*.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36321
10 September 2026

Why Is There No Prescribed Ḥadd Punishment for Unveiling?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Although the Qur’an prescribes no specific ḥadd punishment for unveiling, it is considered a form of corruption and carries a severe penalty because of its grave consequences and the seriousness with which God regards it. This major sin is the root of many other sins and, in itself, encompasses a range of offences.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Display: از مجموع ۳۴ اثر در این بخش