Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
login Login
category محور بنیادین از سند جامع معارف پژوهش‌های عقلی، کلامی، فلسفی و سلوکی

Quran and Exegesis

بازخوانی خردورزانه مبانی معرفتی، حکمت، کلام و معارف شیعی با تکیه بر سنت عقلانی و پاسخ‌گویی به پرسش‌ها و شبهات نوپدید فکری در پرتو آثار و مباحث استاد علی ساعی (عبدالله مشکات).

مجموع پرسش‌های کهف 32
جلسات صوتی ضبط‌شده 15
ویدیوها و نماهنگ‌ها 7
مقالات پژوهشی عمیق 0
psychology
شارح و استاد محوری Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

شما می‌توانید با پیگیری این دسته‌بندی، از انتشار آخرین جلسات صوتی و پاسخ‌های جدید در حوزه {topic} مطلع شوید.

rss_feed
expand_more
Question code: 36464
10 September 2026

How can we reconcile the meaning of “help” in these three verses?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Divine help comes from God alone; every kind of help, whether direct or through an intermediary, ultimately comes from Him. In the verse from al-Baqarah, patience and prayer are presented as means of seeking God’s help. The verse from al-Mā’idah also enjoins cooperation in goodness and God-consciousness, thereby sanctioning this kind of mutual assistance. Recognising that all means of help are ultimately from God guards against shirk.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36453
10 September 2026

Explaining the phrase “Glory be to Him who placed His treasures between the kāf and the nūn”

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The phrase “Glory be to Him who placed His treasures between the kāf and the nūn” alludes to the letters kāf and nūn in the verse «كن فيكون». It expresses the inner reality of the Divine Will, which is embodied in God’s Most Beautiful Names, from which all existence has come forth.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36456
10 September 2026

Why Did Adam Not Return to Paradise After Repenting?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Although Adam repented, his descent to earth did not mean a loss of spiritual rank. Rather, it offered an opportunity for growth and elevation through divine guidance, strengthened faith, and righteous deeds. The verse emphasizes that those who follow God’s guidance will have no fear, nor will they grieve.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36457
10 September 2026

Does the verse «لکل امة جعلنا منسکا» affirm freedom of religion?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The verse «لکل امة جعلنا منسکا» does not endorse the freedom to choose one’s religion. Rather, it affirms the authenticity of Islam and its acceptance by God, with the wilayah of the Ahl al-Bayt (AS) at its heart. A narration from Imam Musa al-Kazim (AS) also supports this interpretation, identifying the “manasik” with the Imam.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36446
10 September 2026

To what does the phrase “هَٰذَا مِنْ عَمَلِ الشَّيْطَانِ” refer in the story of Moses and the Egyptian?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

In the Holy Quran, the phrase “هَٰذَا مِنْ عَمَلِ الشَّيْطَانِ” refers to the quarrel between two men—one of Moses’ followers and the other his enemy—not to Moses’ killing of the Egyptian. This interpretation is based on a report from Imam al-Rida (AS), related in al-Ma’mun’s court.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36433
10 September 2026

Was the Ordeal of Prophet Jonah (AS) Divine Punishment or Spiritual Formation?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The trials of prophets and believers are part of divine guidance: a form of special providential attention and a distinct classroom. The trials of prophets transcend general mercy and belong among the ranks and honors bestowed by God. For prophets, tribulation is a means of elevation; for the friends of God, it is an honor. The greater the reward, the greater the trial.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36434
10 September 2026

Was the Fish in the Story of Jonah (AS) Real or Symbolic?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The fish in the story of Jonah (AS) was specifically chosen by God to carry out a divine purpose, and it fulfilled its task perfectly. The choice of a fish gives the manifestation of the divine miracle a distinctive quality: the fish that became Jonah’s moving prison also became his place of worship and the setting for his repentance and supplication, before finally bringing him to the shore of safety.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36435
10 September 2026

What made Prophet Jonah’s (AS) prayer so powerful that it was answered?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The prayer of Prophet Jonah (AS), mentioned in the Qur’an, has become one of the most renowned prayers associated with an answer to supplication because of its distinctive qualities. Offered in his deepest distress and accompanied by an admission of wrongdoing, it brings together the affirmation of God’s oneness, glorification of Him, and a plea for help. Numerous narrations emphasise the importance and effects of this intimate prayer, describing it as a key to drawing near to God and the most beautiful supplication of those who repent.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36437
10 September 2026

Why Are the Deeds of Unbelievers Deemed Invalid, Even When Their Intentions Are Good?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The deeds of unbelievers, even when they appear good, are deemed invalid and without effect because they lack a foundation in monotheism and sound belief. Such deeds may be superficial, incomplete, self-serving, or performed without sincere devotion to God; alternatively, they may lose their worth because of rejecting the authority of the Ahl al-Bayt (AS) or committing what is forbidden. Islam rests on five foundations, and wilayah is the key to them all; without it, deeds are but scattered dust.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36438
10 September 2026

What Is the Difference Between a Great Reward and a Generous Reward in the Qur’an?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

In the Qur’an, a “generous reward” is one bestowed with special love, unstinting generosity, exceptional grace and abundance; it is usually accompanied by forgiveness and blessing. A “great reward” also conveys intensity and power, in addition to divine grace, and the Qur’an can speak of a great punishment as well. It does not describe punishment as “generous” in this way. Every generous reward is great, but not every great reward is necessarily generous.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36439
10 September 2026

Why Do the Prophets in Sūrat Yā Sīn Not Mention Miracles?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

When the prophets in Sūrat Yā Sīn say, «مَا عَلَيْنَا إِلَّا الْبَلَاغُ الْمُبِينُ» (“Our duty is only to deliver the message clearly”), they are not saying that this is their sole proof; rather, it is one part of their argument. Commentaries cite reports of debates in which the prophets established the truth of their mission through miracles—for example, restoring sight to the blind and healing the bedridden. These reports show that the prophets also used miracles to affirm their prophethood.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36427
10 September 2026

Does God’s Greeting of Peace to John (SA) Indicate His Infallibility?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

God’s greeting of peace to John (SA) at three stages—his birth, death, and resurrection—expresses divine care, grace, security, and well-being; on its own, however, it does not indicate infallibility, since this greeting also extends to the faithful. Jesus, son of Mary, likewise invoked peace upon himself at these stages.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36382
10 September 2026

Can the Existence of the Hereafter Be Proved by Rational and Quranic Arguments?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The existence of the Hereafter can be established through rational and Quranic arguments. Rational arguments include the instinct for survival, sleep and wakefulness, the renewal of nature, and the course of the universe. The Quranic verses also explicitly affirm resurrection, the reward of the righteous in Paradise, and the punishment of the disbelievers in Hell, and describe them as everlasting.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36384
10 September 2026

Why Is Paradise Described with Material Blessings Such as Gold and Pearls?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Describing Paradise with material blessings such as gold and pearls is a way of appealing to hearts drawn to worldly things, while reminding us of the far greater and unimaginable delights of the hereafter. In Paradise, these blessings bring a joy beyond the fleeting pleasures of this world, and serve as good news for those who worship God in hope of reward. Yet the greatest blessing is God’s good pleasure.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36386
10 September 2026

What Is the Tawhidic Mystery Behind the Qur’an’s Combining of Anthropomorphic Language and Transcendence?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The Qur’an’s combination of anthropomorphic language and divine transcendence holds a mystery rooted in tawhid. Anthropomorphic language serves as a bridge for reflection and spiritual journeying toward God. Such language belongs to the category of ambiguous verses and must be understood in light of the clear, decisive verses. The sound doctrine of tawhid is the one set out in the Qur’an: neither absolute negation nor likening God to created beings, but affirmation of God’s existence and attributes without resemblance to creation.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36380
10 September 2026

What Is the Difference Between the Creation of the Earth and the Heavens in Sūrat al-Baqara and Sūrat al-Nāziʿāt?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The apparent difference between the accounts of the creation of the earth and the heavens in Sūrat al-Baqara and Sūrat al-Nāziʿāt is resolved by reference to exegetical reports. According to these reports, God first created the earth, then formed the heavens, and finally spread out the earth. Thus, the verse «و الأرض بعد ذلک دحاها» means that the earth was spread out after the heavens were created, not that it was created then.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36374
10 September 2026

What does “أحصیناه” mean in the verse “کل شیء أحصیناه فی إمام مبین”?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

In the verse “کل شیء أحصیناه فی إمام مبین,” “احصاء” means recording something quantitatively and qualitatively, with all its calculations and attributes; providing a complete and precise record, down to every nuance and subtlety; making a comprehensive and complete record of it in knowledge; and encompassing and mastering it in all its general and particular details. The Clear Imam is the very reality of the wilayah of the Immaculate Imams, peace be upon them, in whom the knowledge of all things is encompassed.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36377
10 September 2026

Why Did Lady Maryam Wish for Death, and Is This Contrary to Trust in God?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Lady Maryam’s (SA) wish for death in the verse «يا ليتني مت قبل هذا وكنت نسيا منسيا» was a heartfelt cry for help and refuge, and a sorrowful plea for the Lord’s special grace. This expression of helplessness was a knocking at the door of divine mercy and a way of seeking His response and special attention—not a sign of weak trust in God or a contradiction of contentment with His decree.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36359
10 September 2026

How Sound Are the Hadiths About Writing the Qur’an and Drinking It for Healing?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Reports describe writing Qur’anic passages and drinking them for healing, but these practices are said to involve particular principles and mysteries and to require expertise. God is the true Healer; no remedy can be effective without His permission. The Qur’an itself is a healing for what is in the hearts, and a guidance and mercy for the believers.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36342
10 September 2026

What Does “Secret” Mean in Verse 6 of Sūrat al-Furqān?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

In verse 6 of Sūrat al-Furqān, “secret” refers to anything hidden from sight and beyond the reach of the senses, intellect, perception, time, and place. This “secret” has a special connection to the Qur’an: what remains hidden from creation in the Qur’an is far greater than what is manifest and apparent. The Qur’an is God’s secret, revealed to us only to the extent that He wills.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Display: از مجموع ۳۲ اثر در این بخش