Peace be upon you. Here we go again with the Yazidis of our time casting doubt and waging a campaign against Imam Hussein (AS.
They say:
⏪Was Imam Hussein’s (AS) uprising about the caliphate rather than the Imamate?
⏪They bring up the story of Orynab—a romantic rivalry—and claim that Yazid wanted revenge on Imam Hussein (AS) because of it.
⏪Can people who call themselves Imam Hussein’s dogs and hold ceremonies in that spirit be justified?
Was Imam Hussein’s (AS) uprising about the caliphate rather than the Imamate?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Imam Hussein’s (AS) uprising was not about gaining the caliphate; it was about affirming the rightful claim to the Imamate and establishing a just government. Those who cast doubt on his motives, without understanding the difference between the Imamate and the caliphate, portray his uprising as a bid to acquire the caliphate. The Infallible Imams were both Imams and successors to the Messenger of God. Striving to uphold what is right is noble and necessary, since it is essential to establishing a just government.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterPart One
⏪ Was Imam Hussein’s uprising for the caliphate rather than the imamate?
Those who sow doubts—worse than the followers of Yazid and allies of Satan—fail to understand the difference between imamate and caliphate, and claim that the Imam’s uprising was aimed at gaining the caliphate. Yet the Infallible Imams علیهم السلام were both imams and successors to the Messenger of God. Any effort to establish an indisputable right is not only not shameful, but has its own beauty and virtue, since it is essential to establishing a government of justice! What is shameful and reprehensible is love of power and worldly ambition, traits far removed from the sacred station of the Imams. The Imams are leaders by their very nature; there is no doubt about this. It is the duty of all creation to accept their governance and devote themselves to their sacred presence. And if the people ask an Imam to establish a just government, the Imam will certainly fulfil his duty, discerning what is possible!
The Imam, the son of Mawla Ali علیه السلام, said:
As though they had never heard God—glorified is He—say: «تلک الدار الآخره نجعلها للذین لا یریدون علوا فی الأرض و لا فسادا و العاقبه للمتقین». Indeed, by God, they heard it and understood it, but the world was made alluring in their eyes, and its finery captivated them. By Him who split the seed and brought the human soul into being, were it not for the presence of those who had come to pledge allegiance, the establishment of proof against me through the existence of supporters, and the pledge God has taken from the scholars not to acquiesce in a tyrant’s excess or a wronged person’s hunger, I would have cast the reins of the caliphate over its withers and given its end the same cup as its beginning. Then you would have found this world of yours—which you take pride in—and the faith you seek …
نهج البلاغه (للصبحی صالح)، ص: 49
Know, O seeker of the straight way and traveller upon the direct path, that by the Lord who split the seed through His perfect power and created humankind through His consummate wisdom: were it not for the presence of those who had come to pledge allegiance, the proof established against me by the existence of supporters, and the charge God laid upon the scholars not to stand idly by in the face of a tyrant’s excess or a wronged person’s hunger, I would surely have cast the reins of the caliphate over its withers and given its end the same cup as its beginning. You would surely have found this world of yours, in which you take pride, and your religion, which you seek … —more insignificant in my eyes than a goat’s carcass or its sneeze.
*The Way of Eloquence in Commentary on Nahj al-Balagha* (Khoei), vol. 3, p. 112