In your view, could Prophet Abraham (AS) have been the same person as Zoroaster, or is this theory unsupported and unreliable?
Was Prophet Abraham the Same Person as Zoroaster?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
There is no strong evidence to identify Prophet Abraham (AS) with Zoroaster. If they were the same person, Zoroastrian histories would be expected to mention events such as Nimrod’s fire, the breaking of idols, or the line of Abraham’s descendants—but they do not. The fundamental differences between the two traditions, as well as the fact that Abraham (AS) is not associated with Iran as a central figure, further undermine this theory.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThere is no sound proof or compelling evidence to support this claim!
If Abraham, peace be upon him, was the same person as Zoroaster, why do the Zoroastrians make no mention of Nimrod or the fire? Could such a momentous event really have been omitted from their historical record?
Why is there no account of idol-breaking in Zoroastrian narratives? Surely historical attention is focused on prominent events and defining features?!
Why is there no mention or record among the Zoroastrians of the lineage of Abraham’s descendants, peace be upon him?!
If this were true, the Messenger of God, may God’s blessings and peace be upon him and his Household, would surely have referred to it when he invited the Iranians to embrace the noble religion of Islam. Yet Islamic history is silent on this matter!
If the claim were true, many points of commonality ought to have been found. Instead, the complete dissimilarity between these two schools is evident. Even where similarities can be identified, they are shared with other schools as well and therefore cannot constitute conclusive or even relative proof that the two are identical!
Normally, the homeland of a religious figure becomes the principal centre of that figure’s followers. Yet Abraham, peace be upon him, is not known as having originated in Iran.
It is impossible that such an important matter could have disappeared without a trace from Iranian civilisation!