Respected teacher, in the question concerning arrogance and pride, you said that the Messenger of God (PBUH) would offer salām to children, and that this practice prevents arrogance and pride; at the same time, this practice is an indication of a special kind of courage that the Noble Messenger possessed, since perhaps this salām was not returned to him in the best manner, or it could have been met with a childish joke or teasing. Please explain salām in detail, state all its effects and blessings, and also explain the limits and boundaries of offering salām, because sometimes a single salām to people about whom we do not have much knowledge can open the door to a friendship that does not bring good consequences. Is it really permissible to offer salām to everyone who happens to be passing by—of course, distinguishing between maḥram and non-maḥram, the observance of which is obligatory?
I always exercise caution in this matter. Please give a complete explanation. Thank you.
What are the effects and blessings of offering salām, and what are its limits and boundaries?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Offering salām is a practice of the Prophet (PBUH) that keeps one far from arrogance and pride. A comprehensive treatment of the subject of salām is difficult in this space, but in general, offering salām to non-maḥrams, to those who commit sins, to hypocrites and to unbelievers is permissible, provided the necessary conditions and precautions are observed—especially in the case of young people and in situations where misunderstanding is feared. The response to salām can also be given gently and from the heart.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe farther we depart from the path of Muhammad and the Family of Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon them, the harder it becomes to follow the Prophet’s sunnah, and the more estranged society grows from his example and way. The real pain lies in turning away from what is right and true.
A comprehensive discussion of salām is difficult within these limited confines. Those interested may consult the sessions at Mishkat on the interpretation of salām in the commentary on Ziyārat Ashura.
When unrelated men and women greet one another—especially young people—it is more fitting to refrain, given the risk of hearts being unsettled and becoming tainted. This is so even though returning a greeting is obligatory; one may fulfil this duty quietly, even inwardly.
One should also refrain from greeting sinners, hypocrites, disbelievers and polytheists, since doing so may embolden them and make their actions seem ordinary. Further, in view of the duty to express disavowal and dissociation, one should avoid offering them salām, particularly taking the initiative to do so. The same applies to certain groups, such as the People of the Book, whose response to a greeting is limited to «علیک» or «علیکم». In particular circumstances, especially in mixed company, it has been emphasized that one should say «السلام علی من اتبع الهدى ».
Where there is a risk of misunderstanding, one should act prudently.
It is also disliked to offer salām to someone accompanying a funeral procession.
عن جعفر بن محمد عن أبیه ع قال: لا تسلموا على الیهود و لا على النصارى و لا على المجوس و لا على عبده الأوثان و لا على موائد شرب الخمر و لا على صاحب الشطرنج و النرد و لا على المخنث و لا على الشاعر الذی یقذف المحصنات و لا على المصلی و ذلک لأن المصلی لا یستطیع أن یرد السلام لأن التسلیم من المسلم تطوع و الرد علیه فریضه و لا على آکل الربا و لا على رجل جالس على غائط و لا على الذی فی الحمام و لا على الفاسق المعلن بفسقه.
الخصال، ج2، ص: 484
Imam Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq, peace be upon him, narrated from his revered father, Imam Muḥammad al-Bāqir, peace be upon him, that he said: Do not offer salām to the following: 1. Jews; 2. Christians; 3. Zoroastrians; 4. idol-worshippers; 5. those seated at a table where wine is being drunk; 6. a player of chess or backgammon; 7. an immoral man (an effeminate man); 8. a poet who slanders chaste women; 9. someone engaged in prayer, since the person praying is not in a position to return the greeting, while offering salām is voluntary for the one who initiates it and returning it is obligatory; 10. a usurer; 11. someone relieving himself; 12. someone in a bathhouse; 13. a sinner who openly flaunts his sin.
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: کان رسول الله ص یسلم على النساء و یرددن علیه السلام و کان أمیر المؤمنین ع یسلم على النساء و کان یکره أن یسلم على الشابه منهن و یقول أتخوف أن تعجبنی صوتها فیدخل علی أکثر مما أطلب من الأجر
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج40، ص: 335