What problems does the philosophical theory that the knower and the known—or the intellect and the intelligible—are one raise?
What Are the Problems with the Unity of Knower and Known in Philosophy?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The philosophical theory that the knower and the known—or the intellect and the intelligible—are one raises several problems. The presence of something known within the knower does not prove that the two are identical. What we know and understand is the product of processing the impressions received by the human heart, and may or may not correspond to reality. A person’s worth lies in the elevation of their thought and the merit of their virtues.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe manifestation of the known in the knower, and of the intelligible in the intellect, does not prove that the two are one!
The human being is a vast system with a distinctive structure. Knowledge, intelligibles and perceptions are the outputs of the heart’s processing of what it receives; they may accord with reality or not, and may be true or false!
Knowing and understanding fire does not turn a person into fire! When someone thinks about imaginary things, they do not become an illusion; when they think about nonexistence, they do not cease to exist. Nor does mistakenly imagining that they are one with the peerless Creator turn them into ...; and when they see themselves as nothing, they are not erased from the page of existence!
A person’s worth lies only in the height of their thought, in the measure and value of what they excel at!
قال أمیر المؤمنین ع قیمه کل امرئ ما یحسنه
A person’s worth lies in what they take delight in.
Even if a person receives no instruction or engages in no reasoning, the essential reality of their existence remains unchanged. Even if they have no knowledge or awareness of themselves, they are still the very creature their Creator brought into being!
A detailed discussion, ان شاء الله, in the near future!