From birth until the end of life, human beings consume food from a variety of sources. Given this, all the particles that make up a person’s body have been borrowed from other creatures. If all creatures are resurrected, what becomes of these borrowed particles? For example, the particles of a particular fruit become part of a human being. At resurrection, to whom will they belong as an independent identity? Or is the life of that fruit—and of food matter in general—entirely given over to sustaining the lives of other creatures, with no independent resurrection of its own?
What Becomes of the Borrowed Particles of the Body at Resurrection?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The eater-and-eaten dilemma is resolved by God’s knowledge of creation: He re-creates without any loss. Each person’s original clay remains preserved and will become manifest at resurrection. The borrowed particles, too, will be gathered and re-created by God’s will.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIn philosophical terminology, the issue mentioned here is known as the “eater-and-eaten” problem. The Creator of the universe knows every form of creation: all beings are recreated without any of them suffering diminution!
Given that the past and future have no place, and the present has no existence either, what creatures perceive is in fact the Creator’s repeated acts of creation from beyond time and space. Thus every created form is present before the Lord, who, by His will, recreates it—or brings it forth in the Hereafter at the Resurrection.
Although each person’s clay substance—the individual’s software package, as it were, the fundamental particle preserving that person’s identity and deeds—remains intact and is never consumed by any being, it appears at the final moment as a seed, preserved and present.
If the All-Creative, All-Knowing Creator so wills, He gathers the particles of any being from beyond the span of time.
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: سئل عن المیت یبلى جسده قال نعم حتى لا یبقى له لحم و لا عظم إلا طینته التی خلق منها فإنها لا تبلى تبقى فی القبر مستدیره حتى یخلق منها کما خلق أول مره.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج3، ص: 251
Ammar ibn Musa relates from Imam al-Sadiq (AS): “I asked him whether the deceased’s entire body decays. He replied, ‘Yes, until no flesh or bone remains, except for the clay from which he was created in the beginning. That does not decay; it remains in the grave, rounded, until he is created from it again, just as he was created the first time.’”