Peace be upon you, respected teacher. In God’s sight, who is held in greater esteem: someone who does not observe hijab but may have committed no sins of the tongue, or very few, or someone who observes hijab but has committed sins of the tongue?
Since our judgments are based on outward appearances, we naturally tend to think more highly of someone who wears hijab. And when it comes to enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong, we usually admonish the person who does not wear hijab. Of course, both are engaged in sin, and no heart is made pure and clean through sinning. But I personally try not to judge people, because I do not know what sins or good deeds they have committed. I leave judgment of God’s servants to Almighty God.
There was even someone I met in a group, respected teacher, who was a cleric but suffered from intense self-conceit. He considered all the other scholars beneath him, to the point that they had to remove him from the group. Later, I came across something—perhaps a hadith—saying that those who are self-conceited belong in Hell. Yet, judging by his outward appearance, one might have considered him among the people of Paradise.
I would be grateful if you could explain this.