My relatives asked again: Why do people throw stones at a devil who isn’t physically there????
Why Stone the Devil If He Isn’t Physically Present?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The devil does exist, and symbolically stoning him is not pointless, because we often engage with the realities behind things through signs and symbols. Stoning the pillars at the Jamarat is a struggle against the commanding self, a declaration of disavowal of Iblis and every vice, and a kind of military drill for resisting satanic temptations.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterSatan exists in reality. Perhaps you mean the symbolic stoning of Satan. How could stoning a symbol of Satan be a futile act? Because we connect with the reality of things largely through signs and symbols. For example, our body is a sign of our reality, not our true self; yet any harm inflicted on the body is felt by the soul. The simplest way to establish this is to note that the nervous system transmits only signals, while the experience of pain is a form of awareness and perception that reaches the soul. The same is true of seeing, hearing, and so on. If the nervous system stopped transmitting signals, or if the human soul severed its connection with the nerves, a person would experience neither pain nor pleasure through the body. It hardly needs saying that God is the link between our body and soul. He is also the link between the symbol or sign of Satan and Satan himself. Have no doubt: every stone that strikes the symbol of Satan causes Satan’s soul pain.
Moreover, the stoning of the Jamarat has other inner meanings. Through this act, a person declares disavowal and rejection not only of Iblis, but also of the Satan within the self, of all satans, both jinn and human, and of every vice and moral corruption. It is a kind of exercise, warm-up, combat drill and military training for the struggle against every form of satanic mischief.
If a country’s flag is set on fire, it is as though that country’s entire identity and laws have been set alight. It is a kind of declaration of disavowal.
Above all these explanations lies divine wisdom. He is the All-Wise, and it was the All-Knowing, All-Wise God who commanded the stoning of the Jamarat.
We should ask pilgrims who have truly performed the Hajj about its effects.
Our use of letters and words is closely connected with the hand that throws a stone or a clod. Throwing stones is the hand’s practical language for waging a practical struggle against Satan. When this act is joined with the human heart, the struggle against Satan becomes intellectual, practical and heartfelt.
Every outward form has an inward reality; the outward is a sign of the inward.
الروم : 7 یعلمون ظاهرا من الحیاه الدنیا و هم عن الآخره هم غافلون
They know only the outward aspect of the life of this world, and are heedless of the Hereafter.