Question 464
Greetings to our esteemed Master.
What is your view of the text below? Is Allama Tabataba’i’s view, which agrees with and follows that of Mulla Sadra, the best answer, or is Allama Ali Modarres’s?
Mulla Sadra and Allama Tabataba’i hold that existence is one in the sense of a single, personal reality, and reject any second reality—whether alongside God or subordinate to Him. In their view, the only thing that truly exists in the arena of being is God Most High; all other beings are modes and aspects of that one Reality. Mulla Sadra establishes the oneness of existence in this sense through five arguments: relational existence, the Simple Reality, sheer existence, the Necessary Existent in itself as necessary in every respect, and infinity. Allama Tabataba’i establishes this claim by appealing to three arguments: sheer existence, relational existence, and infinity. Aqa Ali Modarres, however, by carefully explaining the theory of specific gradation, regards the multiplicity of beings as just as real as their unity, and explains the true nature of the relation between cause and effect through gradation—not through the oneness of existence as a single personal reality. He therefore rejects the mystics’ view—that of the oneness of existence—and then seeks to explain their words by applying them to the theory of the gradation of existence.
Master Ali Saei’s response to Question 464
🌸🔆❄️بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم❄️🔆🌸
🍀🔅🌟Peace be upon you🌟🔅🍀
🔆🔅🌱What we apprehend of existence is the concept of existence, not existence itself. The differing interpretations of existence and the disputes among scholars and philosophers over it confirm this: we are dealing with the concept of existence, and even now we have not reached agreement on the matter.
🔆🔅🌱Since we are dealing with the concept of existence, when we affirm existence to the Creator, we have no right to let our own understanding shape our apprehension of the Creator’s existence. To do so would confine the divine Essence to the limits of our own minds and understanding. Since our understanding and reason fall short of apprehending the existence of the incomparable Essence, to claim that existence is one in a single personal reality is to claim that we have grasped the existence of the Real through our own understanding. If that were so, we would have fallen into shirk and presumption, and transgressed our bounds.
🔆🔅🌱When we say of Him, «لیس کمثله شیء», we mean that He truly has no like. If we affirm existence of Him, His existence will be «لیس کمثله وجود». Since His existence has no like, and human knowledge is never free from the snares of embodiment and representation—whether material, spiritual, intellectual, or rational—how, then, can a human being dare to express an opinion about the divine Essence, or affirm the oneness or commonality of existence?
🌸🔅🌱الصافات : 180 سُبْحانَ رَبِّكَ رَبِّ الْعِزَّةِ عَمَّا يَصِفُونَ