Please critique the following statement:
“When a man has intercourse with a woman, he witnesses God in her.
For this reason, the Messenger of God (PBUH) loved women, because the perfection of witnessing the Real lies in women!”
Hasan-Zadeh Amoli, *Madd al-Himam*, p. 608
A critique of the claim that God is witnessed in women and that the Messenger of God loved women for this reason
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The claim that God is witnessed in a woman during intercourse, and that the Messenger of God loved women for this reason, is incorrect. Intellect is God’s most beloved creation, while angels are without desire. Desire is a test that can lead a person toward perfection or degradation.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterA woman is one of God’s signs, and through interpreting this sign, a man sets out on the path of perfection!
Intellect is God’s most beloved creation in all of existence (ما خلقت خلقا هو أحب إلی منک ) and in its blessed essence there is no trace of desire; yet its station of nearness and witnessing is higher than that of any other created being. The angels closest to God’s presence, too, possess intellect without desire! Desire is, in reality, a test: in passing through it, one either rises to a summit beyond the angels or falls into the realm of beasts, lower still.
Alas for the discourtesy of one who claims to be versed in the literature of knowledge and gnosis. From anyone lacking good manners, every kind of vile outpouring is to be expected!
و لا میراث کالأدب