What is your view of the following statement about «لا کالوجودات»?
“In the case of the attribute of existence, which is an attribute of perfection, we say that all attributes of perfection belong exclusively to God, and that there is no existence apart from Him. If we call ourselves ‘existent,’ it means that we are something that possesses existence as a divine attribute. Thus, existence is predicated of God in the real sense and of us metaphorically. No third possibility is conceivable, as you have claimed—that existence is neither equivocal nor univocal!!! This is an unacceptable delusion. We ourselves also add the qualification «لا کالوجودات» to guard against likening God to anything else, because there is nothing else to compare Him with. If anyone does liken Him to something, that shows their ignorance—their reason simply isn’t working.”
A Critique of the Phrase «لا کالوجودات» and the Commonality of Existence?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The statement “An existent is something that possesses existence as a divine attribute” is mistaken, because something must first exist before it can possess existence. It is an illusion to suppose that existence is neither equivocal nor univocal. Existence applies to God in the real sense and to us metaphorically; no third possibility is conceivable. The qualification «لا کالوجودات» is added to guard against anthropomorphism.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWhen we look closely at his sentence:
His sentence: “A ‘being’ means that we are something that possesses existence as a divine attribute.”
He says: “We are something that possesses existence…” In other words, there was something that, after it existed, came to possess existence… The sentence is equivalent to saying: “That thing existed, and then, after this existence, came to possess existence…” The speaker’s glaring error in formulating the sentence is plain to see!
We ask: What was that thing in the first place? Was it something without existence that later acquired it? If so, it was nonexistence—and nothing can be attributed to nonexistence, because there is nothing there (it does not exist) to which anything could be added!
The rest of his statements were included in the previous replies!