Greetings to Professor Saei, and I ask for your special prayers.
The following text was written by a non-believer to mock a believing woman. I would be grateful if you would critique it.
“Your problem is that you cling to religion with both hands. You like anything that praises religion and religious faith; anything else offends you. You’ve never wanted to be reasonable and admit, even to the blisters on your feet, that you may have gone wrong along the way. But I did.
We don’t have to follow a path just because certain things were drilled into us from childhood. Reason and reflection are the best guides for a person.
They’ve always made us do all sorts of things through fear, threats, heaven and hell, and taken away our ability to think and make our own decisions. Why has no one ever said, ‘Do this for the sake of humanity,’ instead of ‘to please God’? Why do we tie humanity to religion? Does someone have to be religious to be a good human being? Did all those great people who served humanity have a religion?
They never told us these things, in case our minds might open and we might choose the right path—because then they wouldn’t be able to rule over us. Before anything else, a person should have an inner faith: a faith called kindness, in which humanity comes first and last.
I don’t know exactly what true Islam was. I’m no historian, so I can’t say what distortions have taken place in religion over the past 1,400 years. But what my reason tells me is that God is kind and loves humanity. The problems and difficulties they’ve created for people in the name of religion—God never said those things.
Now read the text above once more and think about it.”