Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 223 17 July 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Advanced

A critique of three meanings of the unity of being from the perspective of the Qur’an and the Ahl al-Bayt?

Primary reference: See the answer text 34 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-223

With respect, could you please share your view on the following?
Unity of being has at least three meanings:
1. Conceptual commonality
2. The identity or equivalence of Creator and creation = disbelief
3. God Most High’s continuous bestowal of existence, which entails that all creatures—from inanimate matter to the noblest of creatures—are, in their essence, attributes, and actions, sheer poverty, need, and dependence on God Most High.
Reflect on this carefully.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Unity of being, if understood as either conceptual commonality or the identity of Creator and creation, is disbelief. Absolute existence has no limits and leaves no room for anything else. The philosophy of being is not rooted in the Qur’an and the Ahl al-Bayt, and wordplay in discussions of divine oneness is forbidden. Vague and ambiguous statements can be a way to commandeer people’s thinking; one must avoid intruding into the domain of the divine Essence.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

On Existence 1

If we posit a conceptually shared existence between the existence of things and the existence of God—نعوذ بالله—or regard the concept of existence as having the same univocal meaning when applied to Creator and creature, an obvious problem arises: we would have succeeded in making existence intelligible. This understanding would then encompass the Essence of the Most High—that is, نعوذ بالله, we would have managed to understand God’s existence. Yet whatever can be understood is other than the existence of God. This is precisely the meaning of سبحان الله and الله اکبر.

We should not let ourselves be troubled by this. Just as the Creator creates beings, so too does He create their existence. Both existence and the concept of existence, being and the concept of being, are created. But if we affirm existence of the divine Essence, that existence has no likeness or counterpart; no being can occupy a lower level of it, for that would delimit the Lord’s eternal, ineffable existence.

His existence is beyond existence. It is we who cannot comprehend what lies beyond existence. But He truly is beyond existence, and applying the term “existence” to His Essence is a necessity—and nothing more.

If we cannot find an existence beyond existence, that is due to our own incapacity and weakness. Because our knowledge is limited, we cannot conceive of a third or fourth possibility beyond being and nonbeing. This speaks to our own limitations.

On Existence 2

Existence and the shadow of existence

Even the most elementary reflection can lead us to this truth: an absolute existence, without limits or constraints, leaves no room for anything other than itself. To have a shadow is to be limited and contingent. To regard creatures as the shadow of the Creator is a tremendous audacity, lowering the Creator’s inaccessible station to the level of creatures. Even if the discussion is about existence, and the existence of beings is taken to be the shadow of that higher existence, both claims are an immense audacity! سبحان الله عن ذلک علوا کبیرا!

On Existence 3

Rational reflection on existence!

The prevalent discussion of existence in academic circles stems from philosophy, not rational thought.

In the lexicon of the Qur’an and the عترت, there is no such term as philosophy.

Philosophy is a path to truth and a particular method of thinking. It cannot be called a rational method of thought, because the definition of reason differs entirely from the definition philosophy offers.

The Qur’an’s call to reason can be answered only through innate nature. The philosophical approach to reason, by contrast, is thought divorced from innate nature. Although figures such as Shaykh al-Ishraq have paid particular attention to innate nature, the deep-rooted dependence on philosophy without innate nature remains.

The definition of reason given by the اهل بیت علیهم السلام can be attained only by adorning oneself with مکارم الاخلاق.

A person can attain fully rational thought only when their faculty of reason has been activated. In the school of the اهل بیت علیهم السلام, this is known as جنود عقل.

On Existence 4

In discussions of divine oneness, playing with words is forbidden!

Synonyms may differ in their construction and form, but they do not change the meaning.

What can be meant by an existence that is عین فقر?

عین فقر means having no share whatsoever in richness.

So impoverished existence is existence minus existence: an existence that has no share in existence at all, whose share in existence is zero. In other words, no such existence exists; it is nothing, nonexistence. Calling it “existence” is merely a concession of language.

If we grant impoverished existence some share in existence, however small, then it is in fact part of a greater existence. In that case, we will be accused of dividing the existence of God Most High—who is far above such accusations. If we affirm existence of Him, His existence is «لیس کمثله وجود»: to explain, describe, or comprehend it is impossible. Comparing the existence of any being with that of other beings is an encroachment upon the divine majesty and entry into the realm of the divine Essence; the only result is that thought and reflection burn their wings.

On Existence 5

Vague, ambiguous, and indeterminate statements are a means of commandeering people’s minds!

Complicating language and making it sound specialized is a way of smuggling in beliefs and ideas.

If expressions really are specialized and particular, with their own glossaries and technical vocabularies, then personal and exclusive theories and beliefs should not be presented to the public without explaining their premises. And if they are presented, the audience should not be presumed ignorant.

Let us think a little more deeply about the words and expressions we use!

Relational existence, dependent existence, non-independent existence

We must set aside the niceties. If there is an existence that is dependent, it nonetheless has some share in existence, albeit a dependent one. That is, if He wills it to exist, its existence endures. So there is, after all, an existent reality, and this cannot be denied. Its existence is real, for if it were not real, there would in fact be no existence. And in that case, the existence of any being would be meaningless!

Creatures are dependent in their existence on God, who is free of all need. But any comparison between God’s existence and the existence of beings is an audacity and a crossing of the bounds of servitude. God is the Originator of all beings, and the Originator has nothing in common with the originated, even with respect to existence. The existence of beings was brought into being by the Exalted Originator, but His existence is «لیس کمثله وجود». Applying the term “existence” to His ineffable Essence is purely a necessity. Whatever we understand by existence, He is above and beyond it, for He transcends comprehension and cannot be contained within the realm of understanding!
**On Existence 6**

Philosophy is abuzz with debate over the primacy of essence or existence!

The battle over whether essence or existence is fundamental is so heated that it reaches even those seeking knowledge and understanding.

Entry into the Divine Presence is forbidden!!! Yet, regrettably, such audacity knows no bounds: every self-proclaimed scholar sets out his wares in this forbidden precinct!

If we regard the essences and quiddities of things as constructs of the mind, and call them the limits of existence, while considering the Essence of the Real to be without limit or qualification, then a greater problem arises: an existence that is limited, or an existence capable of being limited! Such a capacity implies imperfection and limitation. The Unlimited cannot be confined by any limit. If we say that the quiddities of existing things are the limits of their existence, and that these quiddities are merely mental constructs, then in reality no such quiddities exist at all; we have fashioned them with our own minds. But what is not real truly does not exist; it has no external existence. An existent without quiddity, then, is pure existence, leaving us with only one existence. Yet the puzzle remains: these things truly exist, with all their limits and qualifications. We cannot deceive ourselves. The relation between Creator and created (the Originator and the originated) is nothing other than that of Creator and created—nothing more. The created exists in the fullness of its being; it is existent. Its essence and quiddity have an external, objective existence. The Creator can be described only by «الله اکبر», for «اکبر من ان یوصف»!

**On Existence 7**

Conventional constructs, mental constructs

If mental existence does not exist, then it is nothing. If the mind posits something that is not, then it posits nonexistence. If quiddities are like this, then they are nonexistent at their very root; they do not exist. The mind itself also has a quiddity, so it too does not exist. Whoever creates mental existence also has a quiddity, so that person, too, does not exist. What a predicament!!! Can someone who does not exist posit anything at all???

Let us not deceive ourselves: what does not exist truly does not exist.

If we are the creators of quiddity in the mind, what is the quiddity of the mind itself? If we also posit a quiddity for the mind, then the mind itself will not exist—and, in turn, neither will anything it creates. So how can what does not exist create something else that does not exist?

**On Existence 8**

یا هو یا من هو هو یا من لیس هو إلا هو یا هو یا من لا هو إلا هو
مکارم الأخلاق، ص: 346

یا الله الذی لا إله إلا هو یا هو یا من لا إله إلا هو
مهج الدعوات و منهج العبادات، ص: 251

یا هو یا هو یا من لیس کهو یا من لا هو إلا هو
مهج الدعوات و منهج العبادات، ص: 307

یا هو یا من لا هو إلا هو اغفر لی و انصرنی على القوم الکافرین
عده الداعی و نجاح الساعی، ص: 279

یا هو یا من لا یعلم ما هو و لا کیف هو و لا أین هو و لا حیث هو إلا هو
البلد الأمین و الدرع الحصین، النص، ص: 337

‏قل هو الله أحد

Let us reflect: every exalted one is humbled before Him—not that every humbled one is humbled before Him. Likewise, every rich one is poor before Him—not that every poor one is poor before Him. The existence of an existent, and the being of every existence, are undeniable truths. If we may compare this kind of existence with the Essence of the Real, we can only say that the existence of every existent is nonexistence before Him!

Ali (peace be upon him) said: "Every mighty one who comes under the sway of Power is abased."
Tuhaf al-Uqul, text, p. 215

Imam Husayn (peace be upon him): "My God, I am the poor one in my wealth, so how could I not be poor in my poverty? My God, I am the ignorant one in my knowledge, so how could I not be ignorant in my ignorance?"
Iqbal al-A'mal (old edition), vol. 1, p. 348

Praise be to God, for whom no state ever preceded a state, such that He could be first before being last, or manifest before being hidden. Every being named by oneness other than He is few, and every mighty one other than He is abased, and every strong one other than He is weak, and every owner other than He is owned, and every knower other than He is a learner, and every powerful one other than He is capable and then powerless, and every hearer other than He is deaf to subtle sounds, and loud sounds deafen him, and what lies beyond them escapes him; and every seer other than He is blind to hidden colors and subtle bodies; and every manifest thing other than He is hidden, and every hidden thing other than He is not manifest. He did not create what He created to strengthen a dominion, nor to instill fear of the consequences of time, nor to seek help against a rival peer, nor against a competing partner, nor against an opposing adversary; rather, they are created beings held in subjection and servants brought low. He did not indwell things, that it be said He is present within them, nor was He far from them, that it be said He is separate from them. The creation of what He began did not weary Him, nor the governance of what He brought forth, nor did incapacity halt Him before what He created, nor did any doubt enter upon Him in what He decreed and determined; rather, it is a firm decree, a firmly established knowledge, and a decisive command—the hoped-for amid calamities, the feared amid blessings.
Nahj al-Balagha (ed. Subhi Salih), p. 96

O company of Muslims, make the fear of truth your inner garment and calm assurance your outer garment, and clench your teeth, for this is the surest way to turn swords away from your heads. Complete your armor, and rattle your swords in their scabbards before drawing them; look at the enemy with a glance of wrath from the corner of the eye, and strike him with the spear from right and left, and deal blows with the flat of the sword, and bring your swords to the enemy by advancing your steps. Know that your deeds are in God's sight, and that you are with the cousin of the Messenger of God, may God bless him and his family; so press the attack one after another, and be ashamed to flee, for flight from battle is a disgrace upon generations and the fire of tomorrow's resurrection.
Rejoice that your souls shall leave your bodies in jihad, and move lightly toward death.
Set yourselves against this dense army of the enemy and the tents pitched with their ropes; strike into the midst of those tents, for Satan is hidden at their lower flank—his hand stretched forward to leap, his foot drawn back to flee. Aim at the enemy with all your might so that the pillar of truth may be made manifest, for "you are the superior people, and God is with you, and He will not diminish your reward."
Nahj al-Balagha / Ansariyan translation, p. 140

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022