First, not all the reports concerning primordial clay (ṭīnat) are sufficiently sound and reliable to stand on their own as proof or as a legal indicator. Even if their chains of transmission were sound, that would not relieve the researcher of the need to examine the authenticity of their wording.
A careful inquiry must conclude that salty clay cannot, in itself, be condemned as vile, since it could have had no part in its own primordial creation! (خلق فی مبتدإ الخلق بحرین)
Fresh, sweet water and salty, bitter water may both be legitimate manifestations of creation, even if Paradise and its inhabitants are created from one, and Hell and its inhabitants from the other. First, Hell, like Paradise, is among God’s worthy creations. Moreover, the association of salty, bitter clay with the inhabitants of Hell is like the assignment of particular angels to them: it does not diminish their standing.
The nature of an instrument also affects the kind of task assigned to it. It even affects whether a particular agent can use that instrument and have it accompany him. Not every instrument can serve as a tool in the hands of every agent, though some instruments may indeed be held captive in the hands of evildoers. The essential point is that there are many mysteries and wisdoms bound up in these relationships between agent and instrument, and their secrets cannot be uncovered through just any analysis.
عن أبی عبد الله ع إن الله تبارک و تعالى خلق فی مبتدإ الخلق بحرین أحدهما عذب فرات و الآخر ملح أجاج ثم خلق تربه آدم من البحر العذب الفرات ثم أجراه على البحر الأجاج فجعله حمأ مسنونابحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج5، ص: 255