سلام علیکم, dear teacher. One cannot expect a child, ignorant and sitting in mourning, to behave like the elder of the family. When the elder of the family is so overcome by grief that فلاندبنک صباحا و مساء و لابکین علیک بدل الدموع دما, can anyone fault the children and grandchildren for beating their chests in the intensity of their grief? لا یوم کیومک یا اباعبدالله
Can someone be faulted for beating their chest out of grief during mourning?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
In the tradition of mourning for the Master of Martyrs, chest-beating and wailing are small matters. No one should fault a person who beats their chest in the grip of grief, for the depth of sorrow and mourning reflects the depth of one’s knowledge and insight. The Imam of the Age (AJ) himself is always in tears as he mourns his grandfather. His weeping draws on the fullness of his vast spiritual world, and his grief and lamentation shake all the worlds to their foundations.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe world would burn to witness the fire of your mourning! یا صاحب الزمان
Chest-beating, chain-beating, wailing, and the like are small matters in the rites of mourning for حضرت سید الشهدا علیه السلام; what matters is preserving the sanctity of the mourning.
حضرت صاحب العصر و الزمان عج is forever in mourning for حضرت سید الشهدا علیهم السلام. Surely, his weeping encompasses the full extent of his greater realm, and with the fire and grief of his mourning he turns the worlds upside down!
The intensity of grief is commensurate with knowledge and spiritual understanding. In mourning his grandfather, حضرت بقیه الله is not merely at the height of spiritual understanding; he is beyond it. In truth, his blessed and exalted soul is one and the same as the soul of his grandfather, حضرت سید الشهدا. Any comparison between the nature of his mourning and that of others is an unmistakable slight!