Hello, Professor.
The imaginal world is said to mediate between the realm of immaterial intellects and the material world. Is its existence therefore philosophically demonstrable? Some Peripatetic philosophers, such as al-Farabi, do not accept the existence of the imaginal world. Are there other ways for the immaterial realm to relate to the material world, or other intermediaries besides the imaginal world?
Can the Existence of the Imaginal World Be Philosophically Demonstrated?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The existence of the imaginal world as an intermediary between the immaterial intellects and the material world can be philosophically demonstrated, although some philosophers, such as al-Farabi, do not accept it. In fact, other intermediate realms also lie between the material world and the higher world, meeting the needs of material beings.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterNo being in this world can be found that is not connected to the Supreme Origin. If we were to list the intermediary realms between the material world and the highest realm, the task would exceed our capacities. Between these two lie realms such as the Realm of ذر, the Realm of Spirit, the Realm of Light, the Realm of the Veil, the Realm of the Ocean, the Realm of Intellect, the Realm of Light, the Realm of the Word, and so on—the Preserved Tablet, the Pen, the Realm of the Name, and so on.
A material being needs the water, bread, blood, and air of all these realms in order to live. It therefore needs a vein through which the life of these realms can be infused into its being. This is the vein hidden from sight in the heart of the earth.
أین السبب المتصل بین الأرض و السماء
Since beings in this world lack the capacity to draw the life they need from the higher realm, this supreme intermediary supplies all their needs, in every respect—life, knowledge, and more.
Yet we may regard each realm as the imaginal form of the realm before it. For example, the Realm of Barzakh is the imaginal form of this world, and in Barzakh the spirit takes on a barzakh form.