Hello, teacher ...:
3) They say that a human being has three kinds of vital spirit: the human spirit comes from the brain, the animal spirit from the heart, and the vegetative spirit from the liver. How has the existence of these three spirits been proven? How did people arrive at the idea that these three spirits exist? Why are they connected to these three organs, and why are those organs said to produce them? What arguments and evidence have been offered for the existence of the three vital spirits, and exactly what do they do? How do the three vital spirits interact with the rational spirit or soul?
How Has the Existence of the Three Vital Spirits Been Established?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The division of the human being into three vital spirits—the human spirit originating in the brain, the animal spirit in the heart, and the vegetative spirit in the liver—has no definitive scientific basis. It appears to be a speculative classification based on personal judgment. In religious sources, the human self is the person’s essential reality, which rules over the spirits governing the body.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe point above and the classification mentioned have no definitive scientific basis; they seem to be matters of personal interpretation and conjecture.
According to the available religious sources, the human self—the “I”—constitutes the human being’s existential reality and reigns over the spirits that govern the body. An ordinary person may possess up to four spirits: روح البدن، روح القوه، روح الشهوه و روح الایمان
Please refer to the answers below.