Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2293 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Advanced

Does the statement attributed to Mulla Sadra about love for boys reflect his own view?

Primary reference: See the answer text 168 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2293

Is the following content really the view of a scholar, or has it been published in cyberspace to defame him?

Mulla Sadra's explicit statement that pederasty is commendable!!!
◀ Mr. Hassan-zadeh Amoli: What Akhund Mulla Sadra said is true, but it would have been better had he not said it so openly!!

A summary of Mulla Sadra's exposition in the Eighth Station, Chapter Twenty (Asfar; vol. 7, p. 171):
On the love of charming and beautiful young boys:
Know that the opinions of the philosophers regarding this love, and whether it is commendable or reprehensible, differ. What can be said upon precise reflection is that ◀ since this love exists naturally in most nations, it must necessarily be good and commendable.
◀ We see rough souls, hearts like stone, and harsh and coarse temperaments — among the Kurds, Arabs, Turks, and Zanj — that are devoid of this love, and most of them have confined their affection for men and women solely to marriage and intercourse.
By my very soul, this love delivers the human soul from headaches and hardships, and directs one's aspiration toward a single thing, namely the love of human beauty, in which many of God's beauties are manifested. For this reason, some of the masters and great figures of mysticism used to command their followers that, at the beginning of this path, they must first fall in love.
The time when the lover's ultimate wish is fulfilled is when he draws near to the beloved and converses with him, and upon achieving this, he desires something higher, namely that ◀ he wishes he could be alone with the beloved and converse with him in the absence of anyone else. And again, when this need is fulfilled, he wishes to embrace him and shower him with kisses, until it reaches the point where ◀ he wishes he could lie with the beloved under a single quilt and blanket, pressing all his limbs against him as far as possible — and even then, that initial yearning and burning of the soul remains in place, rather increasing over time, as the poet has alluded to:
I embraced him, yet still my soul yearns for him — and can anything closer than embracing be imagined?! I kissed his mouth, hoping my inner heat would subside, but this only increased my inner agitation. It seems my thirst will not end unless my spirit and my beloved's become one.

The exact text of Mulla Sadra in the Asfar:
ملاهادی سبزواری:
If you object that this so-called love, how is it compatible with and reconciled to the pure Sacred Law? In reply I say: perhaps the masters and great figures found a license for this in the mysteries and subtleties of the Sacred Law.

The footnote of the same chapter; p. 173
The exact text of Mulla Hadi Sabzawari:
ملاهادی سبزواری:
Mr. Hassan-zadeh Amoli also says on p. 607 of the book Mamd al-Himam: What Akhund Mulla Sadra said is true, but it would have been better had he not said it so openly!!

Ayatollah Morteza Razavi:
◀ Mulla Sadra does not come out and explicitly say that the behaviour of the people of Lot is correct, necessary, and obligatory; he says that taking enjoyment from beautiful boys is necessary and obligatory because they are manifestations of the "beauty of God" — and interestingly, he cites as examples the ancient peoples of Mesopotamia and the Mediterranean coasts, that is, from the very vicinity of the Baal-worshippers whose god Baal is the male phallus, and the vicinity of the city of Lot. And he considers this ancient trait of theirs to be evidence of their refined temperament. In contrast, he presents the Arab, Turk, and other peoples as coarse and unrefined human beings, and reproaches them for not engaging in homosexuality.
Kabala and Its End of History, p. 257

Ayatollah Hassan Milani also, in his book Sufism and Mysticism in Shi'ism, p. 55, referring to this chapter of the Asfar, writes:
◀ The deviant sexual theories of Greek philosophy, under the title of "metaphorical love," have found their way into many philosophical and mystical schools.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The remarks attributed to Mulla Sadra about the approval of love for boys are false and deviant, and should not be attributed to him. Such claims come from human devils who, under the guise of religion, seek to undermine people’s beliefs and lead young people astray. They should be avoided with the insight that faith provides.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

The pen groans at the disgrace of writing about people of shame and deviation; the page lies at death’s door from having to record their vile words.

The people of disbelief and atheism hide their ugly faces behind phrases and terminology. They slyly don the garments of religion, becoming ravening wolves in sheep’s clothing, descending upon the garden of faith and belief tended by seekers of spiritual knowledge. They do not hesitate to tear at people’s innate nature and convictions.

With people like these, there is no longer any need for Satan: in the sheer intensity of their wickedness, they put a hundred accursed Satans to shame. The whispering tempters ought to sit on their knees in these people’s classrooms and learn from them.

Those who care for their own chastity should keep hundreds of miles away from such ignorant pretenders to spiritual knowledge. Alas, that some should entrust the very honour of their faith and convictions to such people!

There is a difference between a wise scholar and an ignorant one—the latter is slain by his own ignorance. ( رب عالم قد قتله جهله و علمه معه [لم ینفعه‏] لا ینفعه‏). Satan, too, was learned, but he was an ignorant scholar. And there are many ignorant scholars whom only close and careful scrutiny can identify.

The boundary between wise love and foolish love is as fine as a single choice. The distance between desire restrained by reason and unbridled desire is the distance between the heights of the angelic realm and the depths of bestiality—and lower still. ( إن الله عز و جل رکب فی الملائکه عقلا بلا شهوه و رکب فی البهائم شهوه بلا عقل و رکب فی بنی آدم کلیهما فمن غلب عقله شهوته‏ فهو خیر من الملائکه و من غلبت شهوته عقله فهو شر من البهائم‏). Those who mistake foolish desire for desire governed by reason open the way for their followers to descend to the lowest of the low.

Before desire was created, beauty and love shone forth. The desire confined to this lowly world imprisons those subject to it in the lowest of the low.

Angels, who are strangers to desire, are companions of divine love. Only dark-hearted devils seek the path of love through the heart of desire!

المرء مع من احب! Whoever praises the deeds of Lot’s vile and accursed people is counted among them and will be raised with them.

التوبه : 12 و إن نکثوا أیمانهم من بعد عهدهم و طعنوا فی‏ دینکم فقاتلوا أئمه الکفر إنهم لا أیمان لهم لعلهم ینتهون
And if they break their pledges after having made them, and attack your religion, then fight the leaders of disbelief—for they have no regard for their pledges—so that they may desist.

The beauty of the world is a manifestation of the blessed Name, the Beautiful. The hearts and eyes of those enslaved by desire are blind to it. Whatever they interpret as beauty through their sullied eyes is, in reality, ugliness made alluring and dressed up.

Beware of human devils who, in their mischief, nurture a hundred peoples more debased than the people of Lot within the cloak of their ignorance masquerading as knowledge!

A warning!!!! Human devils, for expediency and as a form of dissimulation, from time to time don the garments of asceticism and piety, so they can hide beneath them their stench and their wailing!

Human devils must be recognized through the discerning gaze of faith!

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022