Hello, Professor. Some people claim that the mind has the power to bring things about in the outside world—that by thinking or imagining, you can become rich, marry the person you want, or get a car or a house, and so on. Could you analyze and critique this idea? And if someone believes it, how should I discuss it with them?
Can the Power of the Mind Make Your Wishes Come True?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Those who claim that the power of the mind can make wishes such as owning a home or a car come true are themselves working around the clock to make money and looking for ways to pick people’s pockets. Divine provision follows an established order and law that cannot be bypassed; it does not smile on those who associate partners with God. There are two kinds of provision: what you seek, and what seeks you.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterTake note! Those who peddle these bogus teachings are constantly striving day and night to acquire money and wealth. Their only concern is to find new ways to pick people’s pockets!
As for provision, no one can get ahead of the provision that seeks them or that they seek. Nor does thinking about wealth open the way to it, for divine provision does not look kindly on anyone who associates partners with God!
God’s way and law govern provision, and there is no way to evade or circumvent them!
Those who tell stories of becoming rich through thought are either liars, or their wealth has nothing to do with their thinking. If they are telling the truth, why do they charge for their consultations and courses? Why do their factories keep running day and night? If they are honest, let them shut down their factories and cease all activity, so that the whole world can witness their miracle!
و اعلم یا بنی أن الرزق رزقان رزق تطلبه و رزق یطلبک فإن أنت لم تأته أتاک
Nahj al-Balagha (al-Subhi al-Salih), p. 404
Provision is of two kinds: the provision you seek, and the provision that seeks you. Even if you do not reach it, it will reach you.
و قال ع یا ابن آدم الرزق رزقان رزق تطلبه و رزق یطلبک فإن لم تأته أتاک فلا تحمل هم سنتک على هم یومک کفاک [کل یوم] کل یوم على ما فیه فإن تکن السنه من عمرک فإن الله تعالى سیؤتیک فی کل غد جدید ما قسم لک و إن لم تکن السنه من عمرک فما تصنع بالهم فیما لیس لک و [لم یسبقک] لن یسبقک إلى رزقک طالب و لن یغلبک علیه غالب و لن یبطئ عنک ما قد قدر لک
Nahj al-Balagha (al-Subhi al-Salih), p. 543
He, peace be upon him, said: Provision is of two kinds: what you seek, and what seeks you. If you do not pursue the latter, it will come to you. So do not burden today with the worries of the whole year; each day’s provision is enough for that day. If you are destined to live through the year, God Most High will bring you, with each new day, what He has allotted for you. And if you are not destined to live through the year, why worry about something that is not yours? No seeker can get ahead of you in what is your provision; no one with power can overcome you in it; and what has been ordained for you will not be delayed in reaching you.
Nahj al-Balagha / translated by Ansarian, p. 868
و قال ع: الرزق رزقان طالب و مطلوب فمن طلب الدنیا طلبه الموت حتى یخرجه عنها و من طلب الآخره طلبته الدنیا حتى یستوفی [منها رزقه] رزقه منها
Nahj al-Balagha (al-Subhi al-Salih), p. 552
He, peace be upon him, said: Provision is of two kinds: the provision that seeks a person and the provision that a person seeks. Death pursues the one who seeks this world until it takes them out of it; but this world pursues the one who seeks the Hereafter until they receive their full share of provision from it.
Nahj al-Balagha / translated by Ansarian, p. 883
The provision that seeks you is something you must pursue, not merely think about, for it is assured to the one who seeks it!
قال ع اطلبوا الرزق فإنه مضمون لطالبه
Al-Irshad fi Maʿrifat Hujaj Allah ʿala al-ʿIbad, vol. 1, p. 303
He, peace be upon him, said: Seek provision, for it is guaranteed to the one who seeks it!
But the provision that seeks a person depends on their good character and righteous deeds, not on physical exertion to earn a living!