Does believing in chance contradict causality? What do qada and qadar mean, and how do they differ? Is most of life governed by compulsion—in other words, are we mostly on a path we have been forced onto, rather than making our own decisions?
Chance, Causality, and the Difference Between Qada and Qadar
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Chance has no objective reality; every event in the universe unfolds through divine knowledge, will, intention, decree, and ratification. Divine qadar precedes qada: qadar is the design of events, while qada is the decree that they come to pass. Badaʾ—a change in what is destined—remains possible at the stage of qada, but with divine ratification, God’s will takes effect. In carrying out our duties of worship, human choice is enacted through God’s enabling; there is no compulsion.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWhatever a person believes has no effect on the laws of creation. Divine decree, wisdom, and law unfold in accordance with the individual’s will.
Chance has no objective existence. Every event in this world passes through divine knowledge, will, determination, decree, and ratification; nothing comes to pass unless God ratifies it.
Divine determination precedes divine decree. In determination, the events are laid out; in decree, the ruling that they are to come to pass is issued; and in ratification, that ruling is put into effect. In decree, the possibility of badaʾ exists; but once ratified, God’s will for an event to come to pass takes effect, and badaʾ cannot prevent it.
There is no compulsion in carrying out the duties and obligations of servitude to God. Rather, human choice has been given effect by God, the wisest of judges, and it is not possible for a human being not to choose.
Since these subjects have been discussed at length in Kahf-e Soal, please refer to the relevant answers if needed.
The discussion of badaʾ, the discussion of decree, the discussion of free will, and so on.