Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2520 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Criticism of a Qur’an Written in Gold—and the Social-Media Uproar?

Primary reference: See the answer text 22 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2520

Dear Professor, an artwork by one of our country’s artists, in which the Qur’an was written in gold, has caused quite a stir on social media. Some people have raised the issue of hunger among those in need; others have cited reports saying that gold should not be used in work involving the Qur’an. Some scholars have also compared it to the Calf of Samiri. I myself do not accept this comparison: given gold’s durability and the fact that it does not decay, I see no problem with using it for this work. Today I listened to a speech by Ayatollah Araki, in which he defended the work, and I am sending it to you. Would you kindly share your critique of this artwork?

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The artwork of writing the Qur’an in gold deserves appreciation for its role in promoting the faith and drawing the world’s attention to the Two Weighty Things. The attacks on it resemble opposition to religious rites such as Hajj. Proceeds from the sale of the artwork went to cancer patients, and comparing it to the Calf of Samiri is misguided.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

**Page One**

Given the proselytizing role of this work of art, its ability to attract the attention of people of other faiths, and its power to inspire people around the world to turn toward the Two Weighty Things, we should be grateful to the esteemed artist who designed it!

Those whose aim is to attack religious laws and practices rise up against them on various religious occasions, offering irrational and unreasonable justifications. For example, during the Hajj, they oppose this divine rite and obligation, and instead of travelling to Mecca, remind people of the poverty of the needy!

Thousands upon thousands of worthless works of art are produced around the world at enormous expense, and no one makes a sound. But when a work of art inspired by the Qur’an and the Ahl al-Bayt is created, the opponents suddenly remember the poor. Yet the followers of the Two Weighty Things are people who pay their khums, zakat and other specified dues in full, and do not neglect charitable giving.

What is especially striking is that this dear and distinguished artist, after exhibiting this magnificent work, sold it and spent all the proceeds on cancer patients…

Why has this outstanding work been subjected to such an outcry, when its entire cost was forty million, paid from the artist’s own money? Yet no one protests against the billion-toman cars driven by wealthy people untouched by hardship, and so on…

Why is there no protest against the gold lying in mines, hanging around the necks of the wealthy, or languishing in the world’s banks, while this gold—which has taken on the life and standing of the Two Weighty Things and become an enduring treasure in the service of Islam—has been attacked so fiercely?

Was this beautiful work being worshipped, that it should be compared to the Golden Calf of Samiri…!!!!

This worthy artist deserves congratulations for seeing the religious laws and practices through golden eyes…

#Supplementary_Question2520

Dear Professor, since you mentioned that your answer to this question is not yet complete, I’m sending you some of our friends’ views, so that, ان شاءالله, you might also address these points in your response.

[Forwarded from Saeed Hasan Zadeh Delgosha]

**The Gold-Plated Qur’an and False Leads | #Mohsen_Hesam_Mozafari**

The question and answer published by the office of Ayatollah Makarem Shirazi, along with the other remarks made in recent days in defence of the #GoldPlatedQuran—including Dr Hadi Ansari’s response—show that those defending this act apparently still have not understood, or have chosen not to understand, what the real issue is and where the problem lies.

They naively want to reduce the matter to such questions as the work’s monetary value, how much gold was used, where the funding came from, and what the maker’s intentions were. But the issue goes far beyond all that.

The gold-plated Qur’an is only a small piece in a puzzle depicting the reality of contemporary Iranian Shiism:

Shrines whose size and opulence keep increasing; seminaries and religious institutions growing ever larger; mosques and husayniyyas becoming more ornate and grand; rituals and ceremonies multiplying and expanding year after year—and, by contrast, a Shiite society beset by all manner of social, moral and economic problems: poverty, corruption, inequality and injustice.

The real issue is the reduction of the sacred to #ReligiousSpectacle. In recent years, this trend has accelerated, with the direct support and involvement of certain grand ayatollahs and clerics on the one hand, and the political system on the other.

The real issue is the expansion of Shiism’s physical infrastructure alongside its stagnation—and perhaps even decline—in its spiritual and intellectual life.

The real issue is the growing weight of ritual and the increasingly performative character of religious observance, alongside the decline of religion’s ethical and normative dimensions.

The real issue is the reduction of the offices of religious authority to the management of a religious organisation—in a two-way relationship with the institutions of power—and the administration of rituals, under the catchphrase “honouring the religious rites.”

The real issue is that the religious establishment—its clergy and religious authorities—has for years neglected its duty to guide and represent the religious community. For years now, scholars and clerics have no longer spoken for ordinary people, and are no longer able to do so. The passivity, silence and absence of religious groups during recent popular protests are one sign of this.

The real issue is the growing alienation of the religious establishment and its custodians from social concerns and realities. It is not, for example, whether this Qur’an is made of gold or merely gold-plated, whether it contains four grams of gold or forty kilograms, or who it will be sold to.

Please don’t point us in the wrong direction! At least don’t mislead yourselves!

[Forwarded from Siamak Rahmani]

Greetings, and best wishes for your success.

I must apologise, but I wish you had added this qualification to your question to Mr Saei: opposition to gilding the Qur’an is not solely because there are poor people in society. Even if society enjoyed complete prosperity, such displays of luxury would still be unacceptable in light of the teachings of divine revelation. For the way of drawing people to God has never been, and never will be, through outward beauty and luxury. Otherwise, the Noble Prophet صلی الله علیه و آله would have been sent to Australia, Europe or other prosperous and developed places, and would surely have had many followers; the number of Muslims today would then be far greater. Instead, he was sent to a barren, waterless land, and never made use of such means.

**#Answer2520 — Page Two**

To connect the subject of the gilded-ship artwork with the shortcomings of those responsible for religious and doctrinal affairs, the possible weakening of foundational religious activities, extravagance, evasion of truth, preoccupation with appearances and neglect of inner realities—and to attribute all of this to the artwork—is wholly unfair and unrealistic.

Certainly, any recommended act that prevents the fulfilment of an obligation becomes forbidden. Rejecting extravagance does not mean that we should be indifferent to adorning mosques and shrines. Rather, the point is that the inner self must always be more beautifully adorned than outward appearances.

When someone creates an artwork inspired by the Two Weighty Things, does the very creation of that work show disregard for their sweetness, nectar and honey? On the contrary, it may well awaken people’s taste for these two firm ropes of God and encourage them to turn to them.

An artist’s work does not hinder the activities of the religious authorities, seminaries or universities. Rather, it should prompt them to give greater attention to their duties and responsibilities—not become an excuse for neglecting their responsibilities.

An artist has now expressed, through artistic imagination, his love and affection for the Two Weighty Things in this way. The religious authorities, institutions and those who lead them should likewise demonstrate their love and affection by fulfilling their responsibilities. Surely an artist’s work is no constraint on the activities of those in positions of responsibility!

The question of writing the Quran in gold, and the views of the religious authorities on this matter, deserves respect; hadiths have also been transmitted on the subject.

عن سماعه قال: سألته عن رجل یعشر المصاحف بالذهب فقال لا یصلح فقال إنه معیشتی فقال إنک إن ترکته لله جعل الله لک مخرجا.
د بن سماعه عن محمد بن زیاد عن أبی أیوب الخراز عن محمد بن الوراق قال: عرضت على أبی عبد الله ع کتابا فیه قرآن- مختم معشر بالذهب و کتب فی آخره سوره بالذهب فأریته إیاه فلم یعب فیه شیئا إلا کتابه القرآن بالذهب فإنه قال لا یعجبنی أن یکتب القرآن- إلا بالسواد کما کتب أول مره.
وسائل الشیعه، ج‏17، ص: 162

It is important to note, however, that the artist did not write the Quran in ink; he engraved it on metal. The verses are engraved on a metal plaque.

The eminent Ayatollahs should therefore give an independent opinion on whether it is permissible to apply gold leaf to the engraved letters.

Secondly, the artist’s intention in creating this work was not for people to use it as a text from which to recite the Quran. Rather, through the artwork, he sought to express the inseparability of the Quran and the Ahl al-Bayt in artistic form, and in this way to depict the companionship of the Quran and the Ahl al-Bayt علیهم السلام.

It is essential to understand that Makkah was chosen as the centre of revelation and prophethood not because of its aridity, but because of the sanctity of that noble place. Nor is it the case that no prophets were sent to lands such as Australia and Europe, or that those lands were rejected by God. Of the 124,000 prophets, was there not a single one whose mission extended to Europe, America or Australia?!

And, for that matter, was Makkah a poor land, or was Australia a wealthy land at the time of the Messenger of God’s mission?

Yet there is no doubt that this artwork has brought abundant blessings and good, and this cannot be denied: many people who had paid no attention to the Quran and the Ahl al-Bayt remembered them because of it—something unprecedented, even if their attention came in the form of criticism of the artwork!

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022