Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2521 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Advanced

Is Imamate the same as prophethood, and what is the criterion for tawātur in matters of faith?

Primary reference: See the answer text 30 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2521

Esteemed teacher, I sent Your Eminence’s reply to the Monotheists group. Dr. [name] had written a response. I wasn’t going to send it again, since I trouble you so much, but the doctor asked me to forward it. He also once again invited Your Eminence to join the Monotheists group. I should mention that discussions do not take place there all the time; usually I ask a question, and that opens the discussion. And, in the Kahf group, we’ll also trouble you about the discussion that took place. I don’t think it will take up much of your precious time. If you wish, you can join the discussion. That way, I’ll bother Your Eminence less in Kahf. Thank you. I’m sending the material to you.

[Forwarded from Saeed Hasan-Zadeh Delgosha]

On this account, it becomes clear that before Islam no one who was not a prophet was an imam. The term “imamate” must therefore mean prophethood. We cannot say that there was a prophet who was not an imam, since God said, “My covenant does not extend to the wrongdoers,” and the prophets were not wrongdoers. So, in those two verses, imamate means prophethood and leadership of the people. We have no verse that establishes imamate without prophethood. Of course, imamate as a technical term is a matter of debate.

[Forwarded from Saeed Hasan-Zadeh Delgosha]

On this account, the narrators and their religious affiliations have no bearing on the criterion for mass transmission; we should therefore accept mass-transmitted reports from other religions and sects as well, even though contradictory mass-transmitted reports exist among religions and sects!

Second, if the criterion for mass transmission is that it produces certainty, then it becomes subjective: a report may produce certainty for one person but not for another, and so it would have no authority. Of course, matters of faith are open to discussion.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Imamate is not the same as prophethood. Prophet Abraham (peace be upon him) attained the rank of Imamate after undergoing particular trials, and this rank did not preclude his prophethood. In a mutawātir hadith, transmitters across successive generations and Islamic schools of thought report it; the criterion for tawātur is that it yields certainty, not that it be a solitary report. Verse 5 of Sūrat al-Qaṣaṣ also establishes Imamate for someone who is not a prophet.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

It is not the case that “before Islam, imamate was the same as prophethood, or that every prophet was an imam.” Although Abraham (peace be upon him) held the rank of prophethood, he had not yet attained the rank of imamate. He attained it only after undergoing particular trials and tests. His not being an imam did not prevent him from being a prophet; it was possible that he might never attain the rank of imamate while retaining the rank of prophethood.

البقره : 124 و إذ ابتلى‏ إبراهیم ربه بکلمات فأتمهن قال إنی جاعلک للناس إماما قال و من ذریتی‏ قال لا ینال عهدی الظالمین

“[Remember] when his Lord tested Abraham with certain words, and he fulfilled them. He said, ‘I am making you a leader for the people.’ Abraham said, ‘And from my descendants?’ He said, ‘My covenant does not extend to the wrongdoers.’”

Thus, Abraham (peace be upon him) was appointed to the rank of imamate after his prophetic trials!

A hadith transmitted through tawātur does not concern religions and denominations, since it is transmitted by different levels of narrators, and these levels may include people from every class, religion, and denomination (though, of course, among Islamic sects)!

#Supplement_to_Question2521

Esteemed Professor, I am forwarding you Professor Delgosha’s response.

[Forwarded from Saeed Hasan-Zadeh Delgosha]

Greetings, and thank you.

1. The divine trials of Abraham (mentioned in 2:124) may have taken place before he became a prophet.
2. The final phrase of the verse in question (“My covenant does not extend to the wrongdoers”) applies to all prophets, so no prophet is excluded from that covenant. Therefore, every prophet is an imam, since the verse excludes only the wrongdoers among Abraham’s descendants from the covenant of imamate. His sinless descendants, then, are imams—that is, the prophets descended from Abraham.
3. No verse indicates that someone who is not a prophet can be an imam.
4. The two objections to the use of tawātur reports as evidence in matters of belief—the contradiction between the mass-transmitted reports of different religions and denominations, and the personal and relative nature of the authority of tawātur reports—were left unanswered.
5. Would he accept an invitation to join the group?

#Supplement_to_Answer2521_page_two

Among Abraham’s trials were Nimrod’s fire and the sacrifice of Ishmael (peace be upon him), both of which took place during Abraham’s prophethood. Thus, Abraham was appointed to the rank of imamate after becoming a prophet!

عن الصادق علیه السلام انه ما ابتلاه الله به فی نومه من ذبح ولد اسمعیل أبى العرب، فأتمها إبراهیم و عزم علیها و سلم لأمر الله، فلما عزم قال الله تعالى ثوابا له لما صدق، و عمل بما أمر الله إنی جاعلک للناس إماما

Tafsir Nur al-Thaqalayn, vol. 1, p. 120

The rank of imamate is higher than the ranks of prophethood, messengership, and intimate friendship with God. An imam must possess all these perfections in order to attain the blessing of imamate.

عن زید الشحام قال: سمعت أبا عبد الله علیه السلام یقول: ان الله تبارک و تعالى اتخذ إبراهیم عبدا قبل أن یتخذه نبیا، و ان الله اتخذه نبیا قبل أن یتخذه رسولا، و ان الله اتخذه رسولا قبل ان یتخذه خلیلا، و ان الله اتخذه خلیلا قبل أن یجعله إماما، فلما جمع له الأشیاء «قال إنی جاعلک للناس إماما» قال: فمن عظمها فی عین إبراهیم «قال و من ذریتی قال لا ینال عهدی الظالمین» قال: لا یکون السفیه امام التقى.

Tafsir Nur al-Thaqalayn, vol. 1, p. 121

#Supplement_to_Question2521

Esteemed Professor, I am forwarding you Professor Delgosha’s response.

[Forwarded from Saeed Hasan-Zadeh Delgosha]

...

2. The final phrase of the verse in question (“My covenant does not extend to the wrongdoers”) applies to all prophets, so no prophet is excluded from that covenant. Therefore, every prophet is an imam, since the verse excludes only the wrongdoers among Abraham’s descendants from the covenant of imamate. His sinless descendants, then, are imams—that is, the prophets descended from Abraham.

...

#Supplement_to_Answer2521_page_three

It was mentioned on the second page that, when the office of Imamate was conferred upon him, he already held the ranks of prophethood, messengership and intimate friendship with God; even if the office of Imamate had not been conferred upon him, he would still have held those earlier ranks.

The phrases « و من ذریتی...» and «...لا ینال عهدی الظالمین » subtly point to this: among the descendants of حضرت ابراهیم علیه السلام there would be wrongdoers ... who would attain power without being Imams ... a reference to false claimants to Imamate, spiritual authority and caliphate.

The fact that the office of Imamate is not granted to wrongdoers does not prove that everyone who does not attain it is a wrongdoer. If that were true, then everyone apart from the prophets would be a wrongdoer. Yet many people of great stature never held even the rank of prophethood, while remaining monotheists and just—for example, Luqman and Salman, the companions of Badr and Uhud, the martyrs of Karbala, and ... the members of the Prophet’s household other than the fourteen Infallibles.

The wrongdoing referred to here is first and foremost the sin of associating partners with God. In reality, the office of Imamate will belong to the chosen and beloved among the descendants of حضرت ابراهیم علیه السلام. Monotheism and justice are necessary conditions for attaining Imamate, but they are not sufficient conditions.

... عن أمیر المؤمنین حدیث طویل یقول فیه: قد خطر على من ماسه الکفر تقلد ما فوضه الى أنبیائه و أولیائه بقوله لإبراهیم:
«لا ینال عهدی الظالمین» اى المشرکین لأنه سمى الشرک ظلما بقوله «إن الشرک لظلم عظیم»
تفسیر نور الثقلین، ج‏1، ص: 121

Another reasoned argument demonstrating that not every prophet must be an Imam is that, during the prophethood of حضرت ابراهیم, several other prophets were also present, such as Luṭ ... And certainly, although several prophets may be present at the same time and carry out the duties of prophethood and messengership, there can be only one Imam in any given era. After attaining the office of Imamate, حضرت ابراهیم was also the Imam of the other prophets of his time.

#Supplement_to_question_2521

Esteemed teacher, I’m forwarding you the response from Master Delgosha.

[Forwarded from Saeed Hasan-zadeh Delgosha]
...
3. No verse indicates the Imamate of a non-prophet.
...

#Supplement_to_response_2521_page_four

The fact that no verse was revealed on a particular subject does not invalidate or negate that subject. Many rulings have come to us through the Sunnah, and we have accepted them wholeheartedly.

الحشر : 7 ... و ما آتاکم الرسول فخذوه و ما نهاکم عنه فانتهوا و اتقوا الله إن الله شدید العقاب

“Take what the Messenger of God has brought you, and refrain from what he has forbidden you. Be mindful of God, for God is severe in punishment.”

Moreover, during the time of his prophet, Talut was appointed by God to lead and rule his people. This shows that he was their Imam in that era.

البقره : 247 و قال لهم نبیهم إن الله قد بعث لکم طالوت ملکا قالوا أنى یکون له الملک علینا و نحن أحق بالملک منه و لم یؤت سعه من المال قال إن الله اصطفاه علیکم و زاده بسطه فی العلم و الجسم و الله یؤتی‏ ملکه من یشاء و الله واسع علیم

Their prophet said to them, “God has appointed Talut as your king.” They said, “How can he rule over us when we are more entitled to the kingdom than he is, and he has not been given abundant wealth?” He said, “God has chosen him over you and granted him greater knowledge and physical strength. God gives His kingdom to whomever He wills. God is all-bountiful and all-knowing.”

#Supplement_to_question_2521

Esteemed teacher, I’m forwarding you the response from Master Delgosha.

[Forwarded from Saeed Hasan-zadeh Delgosha]
...
4. Two objections to the authority of mass-transmitted reports in matters of creed—the contradictions among mass-transmitted reports from different religions and schools, and the subjective and relative nature of their authority—were left unanswered.
...

#Supplement_to_response_2521_page_five

The certainty of a mass-transmitted report is established by reason and affirmed by the heart. The fact that such reports are formalised into rules, and that no consensus has been reached on a single formulation, points to this undeniable truth: the heart must affirm a report under the guidance of reason. The degree of insight attained by each person or group, and the certainty they reach, varies according to the extent to which they benefit from reason and knowledge. Yet no group can deny that mass-transmitted reports inspire confidence, and no one can take their own capacity for discernment as the standard for deciding whether such a report is certain. A report alone, then, does not establish its own credibility; it must be accepted and authenticated.

The only way to reach a shared consensus on the criteria for authenticating mass-transmitted reports and other reports is to uphold established ethical and scholarly principles. When hearts are adorned with values that cannot be denied, it becomes easier to arrive at common criteria. But it is impossible for divided hearts to agree on a single standard.

#Supplement_to_question_2521

Esteemed teacher, I’m forwarding you the response from Master Delgosha.

[Forwarded from Saeed Hasan-zadeh Delgosha]
Greetings, and thank you.
5. Would he accept an invitation to join the group?

#Supplement_to_response_2521_thanks

I am deeply grateful for and appreciative of his invitation, which reflects his goodwill, friendship and warm regard, as well as his respect for and appreciation of learning, study and research.

However, given my limited time and resources, my inability to do justice to the rights of the members of the Muwahhidun group, and my concern about imposing on these dear friends, please accept my apologies for not joining this gathering of accomplished people. ان شاء الله, when circumstances allow, I will be delighted to join them.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022