Peace be upon you. People say that Ibn Muljam cried “Ya Ali” as he struck Imam Ali. Would invoking the Imam’s name not have guided him? And if he held love for Imam Ali (AS) in his heart, why did he strike him?
Did Ibn Muljam Say “Ya Ali” as He Struck Imam Ali (AS)?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
There is no basis whatsoever for the claim that the accursed Ibn Muljam said “Ya Ali” as he struck Imam Ali; it originated in a poet’s verse. As Ibn Muljam, may he be cursed, delivered the blow, he said: «الحکم لله یا علی لا لک و لا لأصحابک»—the very slogan of the Kharijites.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterA bat has no love for light.
The claim that the accursed Ibn Muljam said «یا علی» as he struck has no basis whatsoever.
As he delivered the blow, Ibn Muljam’s words were the very slogan of the Kharijites: « الحکم لله یا علی لا لک و لا لأصحابک»
The claim that Ibn Muljam said «یا علی» comes from a poet’s verse. It is, in fact, an imaginative rather than historical account, and is open to question and debate.
The poem in question is as follows:
From Layla I heard «یا علی»; when I reached Majnun, he said «یا علی».
Could this valley be a madhouse? Every madman I saw said «یا علی».
A breeze was opening a bud; at that moment, in the bud’s ear, it said «یا علی».
When Adam’s clay had been kneaded, as Adam rose, he said «یا علی».
Even the Messiah spoke of miracles; so helpless was Mary that she said «یا علی».
Was Khaybar uprooted from its place? Surely Ali there, too, said «یا علی».
Ali could not have been dealt a fatal blow; I suspect Ibn Muljam said «یا علی».