Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 3433 17 July 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Did Lady Zaynab Strike Her Head Against the Litter—and Does This Prove That Qama-Zani Is Permissible?

Primary reference: See the answer text 36 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-3433

Question:

Did Lady Zaynab strike her head against the frame of the camel litter, and can this act be used to justify qameh-zani (striking the head with a blade)?

The account is flawed in several respects:

1⃣ The report recounting this act by Lady Zaynab is *mursal* (its chain of transmission is incomplete).

⏺ Allama Majlisi, who cites the report, explicitly states that it is *mursal*. He writes: رأيت في بعض کتب المعتبره، روي مرسلاً عن مسلم الجصاص — “I saw in some reliable books a report transmitted without a chain from Muslim the plasterer.”

💠 How can such a report be used to attribute this act to Zaynab al-Kubra, or to establish a ruling in Islamic law?

2⃣ Shaykh Abbas Qummi:

This report also has problems in its content. Among them is that it contradicts the Prophet’s counsel to Fatima al-Zahra and Imam Husayn’s counsel to Zaynab al-Kubra. Imam Husayn made his sister swear that she would not strike herself or dishevel her hair. Given such counsel, can we say that the noble lady of the Banu Hashim would have done such a thing?

3⃣ The hadith scholar Qummi has pointed out that this act is incompatible with Lady Zaynab’s exalted rank and noble spirit, and does not accord with her status and standing. Attributing the breaking of her head to Lady Zaynab سلام اللّه عليها, along with the well-known verses, is also unlikely for that noble lady, who was عقيله هاشميّين و عالمه غير معلّمه و رضيعه ثدي نبوّت و صاحب مقام رضا و تسليم. There is no doubt that the Zaynab al-Kubra described in authoritative Islamic texts is worlds apart from the Zaynab portrayed by such narrators and transmitters.

🍀Question: In view of the above, why do some religious authorities hold that qameh-zani is permissible if it causes no physical harm and so on?

🍀❄️Answer:
🌸🔆❄️بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم❄️🔆🌸
#Answer466
🍀🔅🌟Peace be upon you🌟🔅🍀

🔆🔅🌱Most of their rulings seem to stem more from personal sentiment than from religious sources. This amounts to introducing an innovation by declaring qameh-zani permissible. If we reflect on the matter, we see that even if it causes no bodily harm—or even if we assume that it benefits the body—this act nevertheless deals blows to the body of Shiism and to the uprising of Imam Husayn that can never be made good.

Rather than considering the benefit or harm of qameh-zani only to the person who performs it, we must assess its benefit or harm to the movement of Imam Husayn. This will make clear that the blade brought down is aimed at the goals of حضرت سید الشهدا, driving those seeking guidance away from the school of Shiism.

All the questions have been raised in the Telegram group “Cave of Questions and Ruby of Answers,” and the responses are from Master Ali Saei.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The report that Lady Zaynab struck her head against the litter, which some cite to justify qama-zani (ritual self-injury with a sword), is mursal—that is, it has a disconnected chain of transmission—and its content conflicts with the teachings of the Imams. Moreover, some religious authorities’ rulings permitting qama-zani rest more on personal sentiment than on religious sources, and harm both the fabric of Shiism and the legacy of Imam Husayn’s uprising.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Text of the question

Did Lady Zaynab strike her head against the pole of the mahmal, and can this act be cited as grounds for permitting qameh-striking?

This account is problematic on several grounds:

1⃣ The report recounting this act by Lady Zaynab is mursal—that is, it has no complete chain of transmission.

⏺ Allama Majlisi, who cites the report, explicitly states that it is mursal. He writes: «رأيت في بعض کتب المعتبره، روي مرسلاً عن مسلم الجصاص»—“I found in some reliable books a report transmitted without a complete chain from Muslim al-Jassas, the plasterer.”

💠 How can such a report be used to attribute this act to Zaynab al-Kubra, or to establish a point of Islamic law?

2⃣ Shaykh Abbas Qummi:

The report also has problems in its content. For example, it conflicts with the Prophet’s counsel to Fatima al-Zahra and Imam Husayn’s counsel to Zaynab al-Kubra. Imam Husayn made his sister swear that she would not strike herself or dishevel her hair. Given such counsel, can we say that the noble lady of the Banu Hashim did such a thing?

3⃣ Muhaddith Qummi has pointed out that this act is inconsistent with Lady Zaynab’s exalted station and great spirit, and does not befit her rank and standing. To claim that Lady Zaynab (سلام اللّه عليها) broke her head, or recited the well-known verses, is also unlikely of that noble lady, who is the foremost woman of the Hashimites, the learned one taught without a teacher, nourished at the breast of prophethood, and one who attained the station of contentment and surrender. Without doubt, the Zaynab described in authoritative Islamic sources is worlds apart from the Zaynab portrayed by these narrators and transmitters.

🍀Question: In light of the above, why do some religious authorities hold that qameh-striking is permissible if it causes no physical harm and so on?

🍀❄️Answer:
🌸🔆❄️بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم❄️🔆🌸
#Response466
🍀🔅🌟Peace be upon you🌟🔅🍀

🔆🔅🌱The fatwas of most of them stem more from personal feelings than from religious sources. This amounts to an innovation in issuing permission for qameh-striking. If we reflect on the matter, we see that even if it does not harm the body—even if we suppose it benefits the body—in reality, this act inflicts irreparable blows on the Shiite community and on the uprising of Imam Husayn (علیه السلام).

🔆🔅🌱Rather than considering the benefit or harm of qameh-striking to the person who performs it, we must examine its benefit or harm to the movement of Imam Husayn. This will make clear that the qameh brought down upon one’s head strikes at the aims of the Master of the Martyrs, driving those who seek guidance away from the school of Shiism.

All the questions have been raised in the Telegram group Kahf of Questions and Yaqut of Answers, and the answers are from Master Ali Saei.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022