Excuse me, Professor, is there such a thing as a smoky body? If so, what happens to it when the soul separates from the body? Thank you.
Do We Have a Smoky Body, and What Becomes of It When the Soul Departs?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The existence of a smoky body in human beings cannot be established. A human being has a soul, an earthly body, a heart, intellect, a fiery and a paradisal constitution, and an imaginal (barzakh) body. Even the bodies of jinn are made of smokeless fire, and the theory that hybrid beings have a smoky body is unsupported.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterA body of smoke, as described in certain articles, cannot be established to exist in human beings. Some hold that there are hybrid beings born of jinn and human parents who have a body of smoke, but this too is merely an unsubstantiated theory.
As for the human constitution, we can speak of the spirit of strength, the spirit of the body, the spirit of desire, the earthly body, the heart, the intellect, and seventy-five faculties. Alongside these, a human being also has a fiery or heavenly nature, mingled with the human soul. Here, too, interpreting the fiery nature as a body of smoke has no basis. We can also establish that human beings have an imaginal body, also known as the body of the intermediate realm, with which the human spirit acts and moves in that realm. From another perspective, we can establish that human beings assume various forms that embody their qualities, conduct, and deeds. None of these, however, can be described as a body of smoke. Even the bodies of the jinn are made of fire without smoke!
عن الصادق جعفر بن محمد (علیهما السلام)، ... قال: «إن الله تعالى لما خلق نار السموم، و هی نار لا حر لها و لا دخان، فخلق منها الجان، فذلک معنى قوله تعالى: و الجان خلقناه من قبل من نار السموم...
البرهان فی تفسیر القرآن، ج3، ص: 341
Fiery and heavenly nature
عن أبی عبد الله (علیه السلام) قال: «إن الله عز و جل خلق المؤمن من طینه الجنه، و خلق الکافر من طینه النار- و قال- إذا أراد الله عز و جل بعبد خیرا، طیب روحه و جسده، فلا یسمع شیئا من الخیر إلا عرفه، و لا یسمع شیئا من المنکر إلا أنکره».
قال: و سمعته یقول: «الطینات ثلاث: طینه الأنبیاء، و المؤمن من تلک الطینه، إلا أن الأنبیاء من صفوتها، هم الأصل و لهم فضلهم، و المؤمنون الفرع من طین لازب، کذلک لا یفرق الله عز و جل بینهم و بین شیعتهم- و قال- طینه الناصب من حمإ مسنون، و أما المستضعفون فمن تراب، لا یتحول مؤمن عن إیمانه، و لا ناصب عن نصبه، و لله المشیئه فیهم».
البرهان فی تفسیر القرآن، ج3، ص: 340