Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 1366 20 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Does a Person Believe by Choice, or Disbelieve by God’s Will?

Primary reference: See the answer text 48 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-1366

Does a person embrace Islam by his own inclination and choice, or does he become an unbeliever, without faith, by Allah’s choice and will?

The Qur’an contains several verses that explicitly state that some people do not believe in God and the Day of Resurrection because Allah’s will has determined that unbelievers will not believe; they have no choice in the matter and are condemned to eternal punishment. Those who do believe in God and the Day of Resurrection do so because God has willed that they believe, and they too have no choice in the matter. Below, we will examine some examples of these verses:

Qur’an, verse 57 of Surah al-Kahf:
— We have placed a veil over their hearts so that they do not understand Our signs, and We have made their ears deaf. If you call them to guidance, they will never be guided.

Qur’an, verse 107 of Surah al-An‘am:
— Had God willed, He would have kept them from associating partners with Him. We have not made you their guardian, nor are you their trustee.

Qur’an, verse 25 of Surah al-An‘am:
— Some of them (the unbelievers) listen to you, but We have placed a veil over their hearts so that they do not understand it, and their ears are deaf to hearing all the divine signs; therefore, they do not believe in them.

Qur’an, verse 7 of Surah al-Baqarah:
— God has sealed the hearts of the (unbelievers) and placed a covering over their ears and eyes. They will have a terrible punishment.

Qur’an, verse 96 of Surah Yunus:
— Those against whom God’s punishment has been decreed will not believe.

Qur’an, verse 13 of Surah al-Sajdah:
— Had We willed, We would have given every person the light of guidance; but My word is true: I will fill Hell with jinn and human beings.

Qur’an, verse 99 of Surah Yunus:
— Had your Lord willed, everyone on earth would have believed. Can you compel all people to believe?

Qur’an, verse 100 of Surah Yunus:
— No soul can believe unless God wills it, and He brings disbelief upon those who do not use their reason.

Qur’an, verse 23 of Surah al-Jathiyah:
— Have you considered the one who has taken his own desire as his god, whom God has knowingly led astray, whose hearing and heart He has sealed, and over whose eyes He has placed a veil? Who, then, can guide him after God? Will you not take heed?

Qur’an, verse 14 of Surah al-Sajdah:
— Since you forgot the Day of Judgment, taste Our punishment now. We, too, will forget you now, and you will remain in torment forever for what you did.

Why, when Allah has said in the Qur’an that He did not will for some people to be guided and believe in the Day of Resurrection, are they condemned to eternal punishment in Hell for not being guided???

And please explain this text. Many thanks, teacher.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The sealing of the heart and misguidance are the consequences of a person’s own choice and persistence in disbelief and sin—not the starting point of guidance or misguidance. God guides those who seek guidance and strive in His way.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

A careful reading of the verses makes the truth of the matter clear. A superficial reading of God’s verses betrays the critic’s lack of understanding, while rushing to make accusations reveals the accuser’s profound ignorance.

Verse 57 of Sūrat al-Kahf

If we consider verse 56 of Sūrat al-Kahf alongside the preceding verse, verse 56, the baseless objection raised by one hostile to God and His Messenger becomes entirely clear!

الکهف : 56 و ما نرسل المرسلین إلا مبشرین و منذرین و یجادل الذین کفروا بالباطل لیدحضوا به الحق و اتخذوا آیاتی‏ و ما أنذروا هزوا

We send the messengers only as bearers of glad tidings and warners. Yet those who disbelieve argue falsely in order to refute the truth by means of falsehood, and they make a mockery of My signs and of the warnings given to them.

الکهف : 57 و من أظلم ممن ذکر بآیات ربه فأعرض عنها و نسی ما قدمت یداه إنا جعلنا على‏ قلوبهم أکنه أن یفقهوه و فی‏ آذانهم وقرا و إن تدعهم إلى الهدى‏ فلن یهتدوا إذا أبدا

Who is more unjust than one who is reminded of the signs of his Lord, then turns away from them and forgets what his own hands have sent ahead? We have placed coverings over their hearts, so that they cannot understand, and heaviness in their ears, so that they cannot hear the truth. So, even if you call them to guidance, they will never be guided.

It is therefore clear who those are whose hearts are sealed and over whose hearts a covering is cast:

Those who knowingly contend with the messengers, despite knowing that they are God’s envoys;

Those who intend to destroy the truth and take no lesson from admonitions;

Those who mock the signs and Book of God and His messengers;

Those who turn away from God’s signs—and so on.

The consequence of this audacity is a particular penalty: their hearts are sealed. In other words, those unworthy of guidance lose the opportunity to serve God.

Verse 25 of Sūrat al-Anʿām:

As noted, this verse is addressed to the polytheists. Divine will—the principle by which the actions of created beings come to pass—does not guide a person who, while persisting in polytheism, has no desire to leave the darkness of disbelief and godlessness. Such a person should not expect divine will to encompass his guidance. If the Creator were to will the guidance of a polytheist despite that person’s insistence on polytheism, such faith would be imposed and would have no worth, since it would come about against that person’s own will and desire.

A careful reading of this verse makes clear that when someone reaches a state of defiance, his heart is sealed. It bears repeating that defiance is a path the disbeliever has chosen for himself, and the penalty is that a covering is cast over his heart.

یونس : 33 کذلک حقت کلمه ربک على الذین فسقوا أنهم لا یؤمنون

Thus your Lord’s decree has come to pass against those who persist in defiance: they will not believe.

Verse 100 of Sūrat Yūnus states clearly that impurity falls upon those who do not make use of reason. Whoever does not seek reason will sink into the depths of ignorance. Whoever turns away from the light will remain in darkness.

Verse 23 of Sūrat al-Jāthiyah:

الجاثیه : 23 أ فرأیت من اتخذ إلهه هواه و أضله الله على‏ علم و ختم على‏ سمعه و قلبه و جعل على‏ بصره غشاوه فمن یهدیه من بعد الله أ فلا تذکرون

Have you considered the one who has taken his own desires as his god, whom God has knowingly allowed to go astray, sealing his hearing and his heart and placing a veil over his sight? Who, then, can guide him after God? Will you not take heed?

The verse is perfectly clear: one who worships his desires and makes his own whims his god has strayed from guidance, and the penalty is that his heart is sealed.

Verse 14 of Sūrat al-Sajdah: whoever denies the Hereafter will, when he sees that it is real, taste the punishment he denied. There is nothing surprising about this verse. God has promised punishment for those who deny the Resurrection, and that promise will be fulfilled in the Hereafter.

A notable point in these verses is that no sealing or veiling occurs at the outset. It happens only after a created being has reached a state of defiance.

Those whom God does not guide are the wrongdoers, disbelievers, defiantly disobedient, liars and transgressors:

البقره : 258 ... و الله لا یهدی القوم الظالمین

البقره : 264 ... و الله لا یهدی القوم الکافرین

المائده : 108 ... و الله لا یهدی القوم الفاسقین

الزمر : 3 ... إن الله لا یهدی من هو کاذب کفار

غافر : 28 ... إن الله لا یهدی من هو مسرف کذاب

But those who seek guidance are guided by the Creator.

العنکبوت : 69 و الذین جاهدوا فینا لنهدینهم سبلنا و إن الله لمع المحسنین

As for those who strive in Our cause, We will surely guide them to Our ways. God is indeed with those who do good.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022