Question 131-1
Does causality necessitate determinism?
Answer:
God is the cause of the freedom of every free agent. He has willed that created beings possess freedom within specific spheres and limits, and this is indeed realized. To call freedom coercion is tantamount to claiming that God’s will is not realized in granting created beings freedom!
The divine decree of the voluntary acts of any agent creates the possibility for them to take place and for created beings to manifest themselves. In fact, the manifestation of created beings’ freedom comes about through divine determination, not through creation.
Does Causality Necessitate Determinism?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Causality does not necessitate determinism, because the freedom of every free agent comes from God, and God’s will has granted created beings freedom within specific bounds. To call freedom coercion would be to deny that God’s will is realized in granting created beings freedom. The divine decree of voluntary acts creates the possibility of their taking place; it does not compel them.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterQuestion 131-1
Does causality lead to determinism?
Answer:
God is the source of the freedom of choice possessed by every being capable of choosing. He has willed that beings should have freedom of choice within particular spheres and limits, and this will is realized. To call freedom of choice compulsion is tantamount to claiming that God’s will—that beings should have the capacity to choose—is not realized!
The divine determination of each agent’s voluntary acts is, as it were, the creation of the possibility for beings to come into existence and manifest themselves. In reality, beings’ freedom of choice is manifested through divine determination, not through creation.