Greetings, esteemed teacher. Given that all beings are true to their own nature, are not independent in their essence, and have an essence that is self-subsistent—for example, if fire were independent in its essence, the Prophet Abraham would have been burned in the fire—my question is this: Is the continued impurity of an animal such as the pig, which is itself impure and lives in an impure way, attributable to God? Yet God is absolute goodness. If we say that the pig is independent in its essence, what becomes of God’s lordship? And if we say that a being took the wrong path in the world of pre-existence and came into this world as a pig, impure, then if we were to ask the pig now why it is impure, it would ask what impurity means. So the pig’s behavior is not acquired. Is the pig’s impurity innate? Does God, who is absolute goodness, perpetuate the pig’s impurity, even though the pig will not be held accountable for it on the Day of Resurrection?
Does God Perpetuate the Pig’s Impurity?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Purity and impurity are defined solely by obedience to God’s command, and the continued existence of every being depends on God’s lordship. God has given beings free will: when they follow the path of obedience, they are pure; when they go against it, they become impure. The pig’s impurity stems from its disobedience and continues for the duration of its life; this does not mean that God perpetuates its impurity.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterPurity and impurity are defined solely by obedience to the divine command.
The continued life and existence of every being depends on the lordship of God, the Almighty and Exalted—there is no doubt about this. The All-Powerful, peerless God has endowed beings with the ability to choose, and this ability is a gift from the Exalted Lord; there is no question about that either. When a being follows the path of obedience to its Lord, it becomes pure: its purity is nothing other than obedience. When it turns from that path, it becomes foul and impure: its impurity is nothing other than disobedience. Let us therefore bear in mind that the Creator of existence determines both the existence of beings and their capacity to choose among different paths.
We cannot, then, regard impurity as something created by the Creator, since impurity, as we imagine it, has no external existence at all. Rather, the Creator of existence is the maker, sustainer and ordainer of the lives of beings, and the one who makes their capacity to choose possible.
Our contemplation of ritually impure things should not distract us from their true nature. Feces are nothing but a form and arrangement of various elements, which should not be arranged in that particular form. When the elements’ improper arrangement is broken apart, the same feces cease to be impure. The only change is that the elements have taken the form in which they ought to be arranged—the form the Creator requires of us. The Creator has given beings the ability and means to bring about this arrangement.
The foul smell of impurities is merely a sign of an act of disobedience, and nothing more. For if the Creator had not bestowed on us the understanding of obedience and disobedience, we would perceive neither pleasant nor unpleasant smells.
The pig has veered from the path of obedience, and it may continue along this path until the end of its life—its appointed time—so that its score in creation may be fully determined.