Peace be upon you. A friend has asked: Can we say that people who see the Imams (peace be upon them) in their dreams have pure hearts, and that those who have not seen them have impure hearts? For instance, some people claim to see the Imams in their dreams despite engaging in wrongful acts. Is this really possible?
And if the dream is genuine, what wisdom might there be in this disparity?
Does Seeing the Imams in a Dream Signify a Pure Heart?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Seeing the Imams (peace be upon them) in a dream is not, by itself, a sign of a pure heart, and those who have not seen them in a dream cannot be deemed impure. A person’s intentions and actions—not dreams alone—are what determine their standing with God. True dreams are a part of prophethood, but devils may appear in the guise of the Imams, and dreams are not always interpreted correctly.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterMeeting the sun is a blessing for the flower, but it exposes every shamefaced soul.
A face-to-face encounter ranks higher than seeing someone in a dream. Many people have met the revered Imams face to face and yet are among the most despised of their time, while others have benefited from the blessing of meeting them and become beloved in their age. Simply seeing the Imams, whether in person or in a dream, cannot be taken as proof of the seer’s virtue.
A dream is one of God’s signs, and only people of understanding—that is, those who truly hold fast to the Qur’an and the Prophet’s Household—benefit from it.
A dream is not always true; it may be false.
People may be mistaken in thinking that they have seen the Imams in a dream. Although Satan cannot assume the likeness of the Infallible Imams علیهم السلام, it can deceive people by pretending to be one of them.
A person’s intentions and deeds—not their dreams and visions—are the measure of their being beloved.
The station of the Infallible Imams علیهم السلام is like that of the Qur’an. Just as reciting the Qur’an benefits only true believers, seeing the Imams is likewise a lofty privilege granted only to people of faith and piety.
الإسراء : 82 و ننزل من القرآن ما هو شفاء و رحمه للمؤمنین و لا یزید الظالمین إلا خسارا
We send down from the Qur’an that which is healing and mercy for the believers, but it increases the wrongdoers only in loss.
At the time of death, both the righteous and the wicked will see مولا علی علیه السلام, but the believers will benefit.
قال علی بن أبی طالب ع من أحبنی وجدنی عند مماته بحیث یحب- و من أبغضنی وجدنی عند مماته بحیث یکره.
صحیفه الإمام الرضا علیه السلام، ص: 87
علی علیه السلام said: “Whoever loves me will find me at the time of death in a way that pleases them, while whoever hates me will find me then in a way that displeases them.”
The light of God has no likeness that can be imitated.
عن أبی الحسن علی بن موسى الرضا ع أنه قال له رجل من أهل خراسان یا ابن رسول الله رأیت رسول الله ص فی المنام کأنه یقول لی کیف أنتم إذا دفن فی أرضکم بضعتی و استحفظتم ودیعتی و غیب فی ثراکم نجمی فقال له الرضا ع أنا المدفون فی أرضکم و أنا بضعه من نبیکم و أنا الودیعه و النجم ألا فمن زارنی و هو یعرف ما أوجب الله عز و جل من حقی و طاعتی فأنا و آبائی شفعاؤه یوم القیامه و من کنا شفعاءه نجا و لو کان علیه مثل وزر الثقلین الجن و الإنس و لقد حدثنی أبی عن جدی عن أبیه ع أن رسول الله ص قال من رآنی فی منامه فقد رآنی لأن الشیطان لا یتمثل فی صورتی و لا فی صوره أحد من أوصیائی و لا فی صوره واحده من شیعتهم و إن الرؤیا الصادقه جزء من سبعین جزءا من النبوه.
من لا یحضره الفقیه، ج2، ص: 584
It is narrated that a man from Khurasan said to Imam al-Rida, the eighth Imam, Abu al-Hasan Ali ibn Musa علیه السلام: “O son of the Messenger of God, I saw the Messenger of God صلى الله علیه و آله in a dream. It was as though he said to me: ‘How will you fare when a part of me is buried in your land, you are entrusted with my trust, and my star is hidden beneath your soil?’”
Imam al-Rida علیه السلام replied: “I am the one who will be buried in your land. I am a part of your Prophet, and I am that trust and that star. Know that whoever visits me, recognizing the rights and obedience that God, Mighty and Exalted, has made incumbent upon them, will have me and my forefathers intercede for them on the Day of Resurrection. Whoever has us as intercessors will be saved, even if they bear the burden of sins equal to those of all created beings—the jinn and humankind. My father related to me, from his father, from his father علیهم السلام, that the Messenger of God صلى الله علیه و آله و سلم said: ‘Whoever sees me in a dream has truly seen me, for Satan cannot take my form, or the form of any one of my successors, or the form of any one of their followers. A true dream is one part out of seventy of prophethood.’”
من لا یحضره الفقیه / translated by Ali Akbar Ghaffari and Sadr Muhammad Javad Balaghi, vol. 3, p. 498.