Greetings, respected teacher. In part ten of your series on spiritual wayfaring, you said that we should reproach ourselves for our sins and shortcomings. Yet self-reproach wounds the spirit, and some teachers even maintain that one should not fall into the habit of reproaching oneself on this path. Whenever you sin or make a mistake, they say, seek God’s forgiveness and try not to repeat it. I have tried this for myself, and self-reproach has dealt a severe blow to my spirit, one that is difficult to recover from. Believe me, sometimes I try not to sin or make mistakes not out of fear of God, but out of fear of that self-reproach. I would be grateful if you could explain.
Does Self-Reproach over Sin Cause Spiritual Harm? Please Advise
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Self-reproach over sin should not lead to despair; it should be balanced by both fear and hope. Once its corrective effect has been felt, let the self-reproach go. Keep seeking forgiveness and work to uproot any attachment to sin, without allowing hope to leave your heart. Being gentle with yourself in the face of personal distress does not mean neglecting your religious duties.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterReproach should not lead one to abandon hope and expectation; rather, the path of servitude to God must be traversed with fear and hope together. Once a person feels the corrective effects of reproach, they should let it go; but whenever they again sense within themselves an inclination toward that same sinful, reprehensible act, they should repeat the reproach, until the root of love for sin is torn from the heart!
Yet in neither case should hope—the second wing of flight—be torn from the heart!