Question 71
How can evil emanate from a God who is pure goodness?
Answer by Master Ali Saei
🌻Your question is mistaken.
It is, in effect, like asking how evil can come out of God!
First of all, nothing proceeds from God, nor does anything come out of Him!
Rather, God is the Creator, and He creates. The Creator is distinct from His creation!
A creature is not part of its Creator (God forbid), as your argument would require.
Second, good and evil are defined in relation to the Lord, and not in any other way.
Good is the creature that obeys its Lord and is thereby beloved in God’s presence; evil is the creature that disobeys its Lord and incurs divine displeasure!
Good and evil (in the sense arising from ignorance) are defined solely by obedience and disobedience!
Ugliness and wickedness consist solely in being contrary to God’s approval, and nothing else.
How Can Evil Emanate from a God Who Is Pure Goodness?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Evil does not emanate from God. Rather, God is the Creator, who creates both good and evil (in the sense arising from ignorance). Good is the creature that obeys its Lord and is thereby beloved in God’s presence; evil is the creature that disobeys its Lord and incurs divine displeasure. Ugliness and wickedness consist solely in being contrary to God’s approval.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterQuestion 71
How can evil come from a God who is pure goodness?
Master Ali Saei’s answer
🌻Your question rests on a mistaken premise.
In effect, you are asking how evil could come from God!
First, nothing emanates from God or comes out of Him. Rather, God is the Creator, and He creates; the Creator is distinct from His creation. A creature is not part of its Creator (نعوذ بالله)—otherwise, your argument would hold.
Second, good and evil are defined in relation to the Lord, not to anything else.
Good is the creature that obeys the Lord and is thereby made beloved in God’s presence; evil is the creature that disobeys the Lord and thereby incurs divine displeasure.
Good and evil—at least in the sense rooted in ignorance—are not defined solely by obedience and disobedience.
The ugliness and wickedness that exist are nothing but the absence of God’s approval, nothing else.