سلام علیکم
# Supplement to Question 3302
Esteemed teacher, you were right to say that expressing an opinion about God’s acts is wrong. But these words were part of a conversation between me and my own lower self. May God forgive me: when reproaching my lower self, I spare no reproachful words. Words of censure that I would never use against any of God’s servants, I use against myself, because I believe the lower self must be subdued and not given free rein. When it stirs, Satan takes advantage of it.
Here, the matter can be divided into several parts: the lower self must be brought under control, as must the mind; we must also rein in our worldly desires, for most of our afflictions arise from them. And then there is the purification of the heart, whose corruption also stems from the lower self. Please explain each of these matters to me. For instance, we say that we do not know how to purify the heart. Is there something we must do ourselves, or should we ask God to do it for us?
How ignorant and powerless we are when it comes to safeguarding the trust God has placed in our care. May God Himself help us, ان شاءالله.
Esteemed teacher, sometimes I find myself spending several days wholly in God’s presence, and everything feels wonderful and right. If I were alone for a month, being with God would leave me with no need of anyone else for company. Then, little by little, it seems as though I am coming down from that height. Suddenly I realize how far I have drifted again. I am not committing any particular sin or doing anything in particular. I try to be mindful; perhaps I am still in God’s presence without realizing it, or perhaps I have fallen from that state. I then long for those few days when I was in God’s presence. Since a person is constantly changing, perhaps it is wrong of me to expect that state to last forever. A person’s spiritual and emotional condition also plays a part. Sometimes we are ill, and our mood and spirit are out of balance; or something happens in the family that occupies our thoughts and attention, causing us to fall from that state. I still do not know.
Sometimes, dear teacher, you could help us grow and progress in ways we would not even know to ask you about. For example, the Andisheh program seemed to me a kind of mind-training program, and there may be other programs that I know nothing about. Your students have access to you, and you hold classes for them; perhaps they therefore have no need for programs in the group. But we have been left entirely without such opportunities. I do not know whether everyone’s lack of interest is why these programs are not held or are discontinued. In any case, we are still waiting eagerly for a program in the group.
Please do not withhold them from us.
ان شاءالله May God grant you all that He bestows upon His good servants.