In light of the following hadith, please clarify the limits of praise and blame:
Imam al-Sadiq (AS):
لایصیر العبد عبدا خالصا لله حتى یصیر المدح و الذم عنده سواء ؛
*Bihār al-Anwār*, vol. 73, p. 294
Imam al-Sadiq (AS):
A person does not become a sincere servant of God until praise and blame are equal in his eyes.
How Does Hadith Define the Limits of Praise and Blame?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The hadith of Imam al-Sadiq (AS) about praise and blame being equal in the eyes of a sincere person describes only that person’s inner state; it does not set specific limits for praise or blame. True sincerity is attained when a person regards people’s praise and criticism as equal and seeks only God’s pleasure.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe hadith speaks only of the state of the sincere person. It addresses praise and blame in absolute terms and says nothing about their limits!
For believers, being equally unmoved by people’s praise and blame is a clear sign of sincerity.
Anyone who acts for God’s pleasure is unaffected by people’s anger or approval.
The sincere person is a devoted servant of God. He does not trade his sincerity for people’s praise or blame, or let concern for their opinions taint it with shirk.
قال النبی ص إن لکل حق حقیقه و ما بلغ عبد حق حقیقیه الإخلاص حتى لا یحب أن یحمد على شیء من عمل الله
مشكاه الأنوار فی غرر الأخبار، النص، ص: 11
Everything has a reality. A believer does not attain the reality of sincerity unless he dislikes being praised by others for anything he does for God.
The sincere person does not make people’s praise or blame the measure of his deeds!
The sincere person seeks only God’s pleasure, not people’s praise or blame!
The sincere person is God’s servant, not a captive of people’s praise or blame!
و أدنى حد الإخلاص بذل العبد طاقته ثم لا یجعل لعمله عند الله قدرا فیوجب به على ربه مکافأه بعمله لعلمه أنه لو طالبه بوفاء حق العبودیه لعجز
مصباح الشریعه، ص: 37
Imam al-Sadiqعلیه السلام said: The least sign of sincerity is that a person strives in obedience and worship, yet attaches no importance to his own deeds and does not consider himself entitled to anything from God. For the servant knows that if God were to ask His servants for true worship, they would all be incapable of fulfilling it.